Pakistan, Afghanistan agree to boost trade, lower border tensions

Al Jazeera

Pakistan and Afghanistan’s Taliban government have agreed to boost trade and lower tensions along their border amid a surge in attacks on Pakistani security forces, officials said.

Pakistani Foreign Minister Bilawal Bhutto Zardari and Afghanistan’s Taliban-appointed foreign minister, Amir Khan Muttaqi, struck the deal on Sunday in Islamabad, according to Pakistan’s foreign ministry.

The agreement is designed to improve bilateral trade, combat “terrorism” and boost bilateral ties.

According to a Pakistani foreign ministry statement, Bhutto Zardari and Muttaqi on Sunday “held a candid and in-depth exchange on key issues of mutual concern, including peace and security, as well as trade and connectivity”.

The two sides “reaffirmed their desire to pursue continuous and practical engagement”, it said.

According to the Afghan embassy, Muttaqi and his delegation met Bhutto Zardari and other officials. “During the meeting, matters of mutual interest, Afghan-Pak political, economic, and transit relations as well as challenges of Afghan Refugees in Pakistan have been discussed,” it said on Twitter early on Monday.

Pakistan’s military said Muttaqi also met General Asim Munir, the army chief, to discuss “issues of mutual interest including aspects related to regional security, border management, and formalisation of bilateral security mechanisms for improvement in the current security environment”.

Munir sought enhanced cooperation to “effectively tackle the common challenges of terrorism and extremism”, the statement added.

Relations between Pakistan and Afghanistan have featured ups and down in the past year.

In February, the two sides shut the main Afghan-Pakistan border crossing at Torkham, stranding people and trucks carrying food and essential items. After a Pakistani delegation travelled to Kabul for talks on the crisis, the border was reopened after a week and Muttaqi’s visit to Islamabad was planned.

The Taliban government of Afghanistan has been shunned by most of the international community for the harsh and restrictive measures they have imposed since seizing power in August 2021, when the United States and NATO troops were in the final weeks of their pullout from the country after 20 years of war.

The Taliban has banned girls from education beyond the sixth grade and barred women from most jobs and public life.

Pakistan has lately expressed concern over a surge of deadly attacks across the country by the Pakistan Taliban – an independent armed group that is allied with and allegedly sheltered by the Taliban in Afghanistan.

Islamabad has demanded from the Taliban in Kabul that they do more to rein in anti-Pakistani groups such as the Pakistan Taliban – also known as TTP – which has stepped up attacks on Pakistani security forces in recent months.

Saad Muhammad, former Pakistani military attaché to Kabul and defence analyst, told Al Jazeera he was hopeful of a “positive outcome” and that the Pakistani concerns will be taken on board by the Taliban government.

“When Pakistan sent a high-level delegation in February, we saw that the number of violent attacks emanating from the Afghan soil dropped down, which showed that the Afghan government took action,” he said.

“If Afghanistan wants other countries to invest and help improve its socioeconomic conditions, it has to take onboard these suggestions and bring some reform in their governance.”

Earlier on Sunday, Bhutto Zardari and Muttaqi also held talks with China’s Foreign Minister Qin Gang, a departure from recent years when such dialogue had been on hold, according to analysts, who say Beijing is expanding its influence in the region.

China has also played a role in the resumption of Saudi Arabia-Iran diplomatic ties.

In Pakistan, Beijing is bankrolling the so-called China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) – a sprawling package that includes such projects as road and power plant construction and boosting agriculture production.

The package is considered a lifeline for the Muslim-majority nation, which is currently facing one of its worst economic crisis amid stalled talks on a bailout with the International Monetary Fund.

CPEC, also known as the One Road Project, is part of China’s Belt and Road Initiative, a global endeavour aimed at reconstituting the ancient Silk Road and linking China to all corners of Asia.

Qin arrived in Islamabad on Friday and met President Arif Alvi, Bhutto Zardari and powerful army chief General Munir.

During these meetings, he was assured that Pakistan will boost security for all Chinese nationals working on multibillion-dollar projects in cash-strapped Pakistan.

China has been demanding more security from Pakistan for its nationals residing and working in the Islamic country since 2021, when a suicide bomber killed nine Chinese and four Pakistanis in an attack in the volatile northwest.

Defence analyst Muhammad told Al Jazeera that China also stressed in the meeting that the concerns of regional countries are valid and that the Taliban must act to safeguard its neighbours’ interests.

“However, the world too must realise that abandoning Afghanistan is not a solution. It is imperative to keep them engaged and nudge them towards required reforms,” he said.

SOURCE: AL JAZEERA AND NEWS AGENCIES

 


Pakistan, Afghanistan agree to boost trade, lower border tensions
read more

Russia Expects ‘Taliban’ to Form Inclusive Govt: Lavrov

The Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov said that they expect “Taliban leaders” to fulfill their promises on forming an inclusive government, “not only in terms of ethnic groups but also by ensuring the presence of the entire spectrum of Afghanistan’s political forces.”

These promises, Lavrov said have “yet to be done.”

“We are monitoring the implementation of their assurances that they will respect human rights, ensure security in the territory of Afghanistan, and eradicate the threats of terrorism and drug trafficking. All of our SCO colleagues have taken a united position on this,” he said.

Speaking to reporters after the Shanghai Cooperation Organization meeting, Lavrov claimed that there is convincing evidence to the “effect that the United States supports the terrorist groups entrenched in the territory of Afghanistan.”

These terrorist groups, according to Lavrov, “are opposed to the Taliban, including the Islamic State, the Islamic Movement of East Turkestan, and Al-Qaeda.”

“The Americans have not abandoned their attempts to reintroduce US military infrastructure in the region surrounding Afghanistan, in Central Asia. Everyone is well aware of the serious threat inherent in these attempts. We will resolutely oppose them,” he said.

The political analysts gave various opinions in this regard:

“Everyone knows that the main condition for getting out of the crisis is to consider the realities in Afghanistan, form an inclusive government and recognize the fundamental rights of the people of Afghanistan,” said Sayed Jawad Sijadi, political analyst.

The Islamic Emirate has not commented on Lavrov’s claim regarding the US’s support to terrorists in Afghanistan.

However, the deputy spokesman of the Islamic Emirate, Bilal Karimi, in response to Moscow’s call to form an inclusive government, said that the interim government is “inclusive.”

“The formation of the government is inclusive … No has been dismissed, and also, on the political level there are figures from all ethnic groups and provinces,” he said.

Earlier, the foreign ministers of India, Russia and Pakistan on Friday called for a representative government in Afghanistan and the protection of women’s rights.

Russia Expects ‘Taliban’ to Form Inclusive Govt: Lavrov
read more

Zardari: China-Pakistan Meeting Stressed Need for Afghan Stability

Muttaqi attended the 5th China-Pakistan-Afghanistan Trilateral foreign ministers’ dialogue on Saturday.

The Pakistan Foreign Minister Bilawal Bhutto Zardari said that in the meeting with the Chinese Foreign Minister, Qin Gang the two sides stressed the need for peace and stability in Afghanistan.

This comes as the acting Foreign Minister, Amir Khan Muttaqi, is also on a visit to Pakistan.

Muttaqi attended the 5th China-Pakistan-Afghanistan Trilateral foreign ministers’ dialogue on Saturday.

Bhutto said that they “held productive discussions on political engagement, counter terrorism, trade & connectivity.”

Meanwhile, a statement from the Pakistan-China Foreign Ministers’ Strategic Dialogue said that the meeting stressed the need for peace and stability in Afghanistan, saying it is vital for socio-economic development, connectivity and prosperity in the region.

The participants underscored the need for the international community to provide continued assistance and support to Afghanistan including through the freeing of Afghanistan’s overseas financial assets, the statement said, adding that they also “agreed to continue their humanitarian and economic assistance for the Afghan people and enhance development cooperation in Afghanistan, including through extension of CPEC to Afghanistan.”

Meanwhile, the CGTN reported that Qin in a meeting with Muttaqi called for “advancing China-Pakistan-Afghanistan cooperation dialogue on the principles of mutual benefit and win-win results.”

China will, as always, respect Afghanistan’s sovereignty, independence and territorial integrity and deepen bilateral cooperation in various fields to help Afghanistan realize self-reliance, peace, stability, development and prosperity at an early date, Qin said as quoted by CGTN.

Muttaqi was accompanied by the acting Minister of Industry and Mines, Nooruddin Azizi, who met with the Commerce Minister of Pakistan, Syed Naveed Qamar, in Islamabad.

In the meeting they discussed bilateral commerce and solving trade challenges between the two countries, the Afghanistan Embassy in Islamabad said on Twitter.

“The issues related to transit, economic, trade and Afghan refugees based in Pakistan were discussed and they will have other meetings on other issues. The details will be shared later,” said deputy spokesman for the Islamic Emirate, Bilal Karimi.

“China is interested in Afghanistan now more than ever, either economically or politically,” said Tahir Khan, a Pakistani journalist.

Muttaqi’s visit to abroad is the second in less than one month.

Zardari: China-Pakistan Meeting Stressed Need for Afghan Stability
read more

US Assistance to Afghanistan ‘Does Not Benefit Taliban’: Spokesman

Earlier, SIGAR said that there were 133 access incident reports in January 2023.

US State Department’s deputy spokesperson Vedant Patel at a press briefing responded to a question about the latest Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction report, saying “US assistance in Afghanistan does not benefit the Taliban.”

 

According to the SIGAR’s report, the incidents included one aid worker being injured, 15 aid workers arrested, Islamic Emirate authorities conducting a search of an NGO, and 42 incidents where women could not access work.

“We are confident that US assistance to Afghanistan does not benefit the Taliban,” Patel said. “We continue to be the largest humanitarian donor to Afghanistan, and we are very confident in the mechanisms that we have in place – working with the UN, working with other entities in the region – to ensure that the aid that we do provide does not in any way benefit the Taliban, and instead goes towards the people of Afghanistan, who our commitment to continues to endure.”

Deputy Minister of Economy said that the Islamic Emirate has the role of monitoring policy.

“The Islamic Emirate is only monitoring the aid delivery and there is no interference in the activities of aid agencies,” said Abdul Latif Nazari, Deputy Minister of Economy.

Analysts said international aid is not being provided transparently in Afghanistan.

“Even if there is no corruption, half of the fund is provided to the people who deserve it and its benefits is not widely reaching the people,” said Azraksh Hafizi, an analyst.

Meanwhile, the Chinese special envoy for Afghanistan, Yue Xiaoyong said the US should take responsibility for reconstruction of Afghanistan.

“The US must take responsibility for reconstruction of Afghanistan’s current and future because the 20 years of military invasion of the US caused big problems. We alongside other countries called on the US to release the Afghanistan’s assets,” he told the CCTV.

This comes as a top US aid official, quoted by Reuters, said that the Afghan people are in for a “very difficult year ahead,” as donors grapple with challenging the current administration “crackdown on women and girls, more crises around the world and overall less funding.”

US Assistance to Afghanistan ‘Does Not Benefit Taliban’: Spokesman
read more

Pakistan set to host trilateral dialogue with China, Afghanistan

By

In addition to attending the fifth round of the trilateral dialogue between the three countries on Saturday, the two foreign ministers will also participate in bilateral discussions with their Pakistani counterpart Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari.

Muttaqi, Afghanistan’s interim foreign minister, was granted a travel ban exemption by the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) earlier this month allowing him to travel to Pakistan. He has long been subjected to a travel ban, asset freeze and arms embargo under UNSC sanctions.

“The government of Afghanistan wants to hold comprehensive talks on bilateral political-commercial relations, regional stability and transit between Afghanistan and Pakistan,” Ziad Ahmad Takkal, deputy spokesperson of the Afghan foreign ministry, said on Friday.

While this will be the Chinese foreign minister’s first visit to Pakistan, Muttaqi last travelled to Pakistan in November 2021, just a few months after the Afghan Taliban took control in Kabul.

The visit to Pakistan by the Afghan minister comes in the same week the UN hosted a conference on Afghanistan in Doha, Qatar, without inviting the country’s Taliban rulers.

Addressing the Doha conference on May 2, UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres condemned the Taliban’s suppression of women’s rights in Afghanistan, including the ban on education.

“Let me be crystal clear, we will never be silent in the face of unprecedented systemic attacks on women’s and girls’ rights. We’ll always speak out when millions of women and girls are being silenced and erased from sight,” Guterres said.

“The meeting was about developing a common international approach, not about recognition of the de facto Taliban authorities,” Guterres told reporters in Doha.

Pakistan maintains close ties with its northwestern neighbour. The two countries share a 2,600 km-long (1,660 miles) border, also known as the Durand Line. However, Muttaqi’s visit comes at a time when Pakistan has seen a dramatic increase in violent attacks in the northwestern province of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and the southwestern province of Balochistan, both of which border Afghanistan.

Authorities in Pakistan allege the attacks are launched from within Afghan territory by Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP), an armed group ideologically aligned with the Afghan Taliban. However, despite the exchange of terse words between the authorities of both countries, Pakistan has continued to hold talks with the Afghan Taliban without officially recognising them as the country’s lawful government.

‘Positive progress’

In his address to the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) in India on Friday, Pakistan’s Foreign Minister Bhutto-Zardari urged the international community to “meaningfully engage” with the interim Afghan government.

Abdul Syed, an expert on Pakistan and Afghanistan, said Muttaqi’s visit to Islamabad was an important development in relations between the two countries, particularly in light of recent tensions.

“After TTP’s repeated attacks in the last few months and the Police Line [an area in the city where important government installations are located] bombing in Peshawar in January this year, Pakistan raised objections with the Afghan government. But they were given brusque responses from Muttaqi. So, for him to make this visit now can be seen as a softening of stance and positive progress,” the Sweden-based Syed told Al Jazeera.

China, the third participant in the dialogue, also has significant interests in the other two countries.

Beijing is Pakistan’s key economic and defence partner and has invested heavily in Pakistan, headlining with $60bn in the ambitious China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) project. However, multiple attacks by armed groups have targeted Chinese nationals and their interests in Pakistan in recent years.

Chinese firm signed a multimillion-dollar investment contract in January this year, the first significant foreign investment in the country since August 2021 when the Taliban took over.

In March 2022, then-Chinese foreign minister Wang Yi also made a surprise visit to Kabul where he met the Taliban leaders “to discuss various issues, including the extension of political relations, economic, and transit cooperation”.

Some observers believe that the Chinese involvement in Afghanistan is more to do with security concerns than economic interests.

ETIM is an al-Qaeda-affiliated armed group that has conducted attacks on China in its pursuit of the creation of “East Turkistan” on the Chinese mainland.

“China has maintained its diplomatic presence… with the Afghan contact group and other multilateral forums under the SCO and beyond, which means the Chinese are well placed to at least mitigate immediate security threats,” Raza told Al Jazeera.

In the aftermath of the UN conference in Doha, which excluded the Taliban, Raza believes non-engagement with Afghanistan’s leadership is unproductive.

“Regardless of what the UN have done, there is a need to socialise the Taliban into the international norms without extending them full diplomatic recognition. In the absence of domestic opposition and sufficient regional support, the policy of non-engagement will hardly have the desired impacts,” he said.

“Similarly, though, the Afghan Taliban too realise that despite any diplomatic progress they make in the region, it is imperative upon them to maintain cordial ties with Pakistan.”

SOURCE: AL JAZEERA
Pakistan set to host trilateral dialogue with China, Afghanistan
read more

India, Russia, Pakistan urge Taliban to respect rights of all Afghans

By

Reuters
5 May 2023

GOA, India, May 5 (Reuters) – The foreign ministers of India, Russia and Pakistan on Friday called for a representative government in Afghanistan and the protection of women’s rights, almost two years after the Islamist Taliban swept to power in Kabul.

They were speaking at the day-long meeting of foreign ministers of the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) in the Indian coastal resort state of Goa, just ahead of a meeting scheduled over the weekend in Pakistan between the foreign ministers of Pakistan, China and Afghanistan.

“The unfolding situation in Afghanistan remains at the centre of our attention. Our efforts should be directed towards the welfare of the Afghan people,” Indian Foreign Minister Subrahmanyam Jaishankar said.

“Our immediate priorities include providing humanitarian assistance, ensuring a truly inclusive and representative government, combating terrorism and drug trafficking, and preserving the rights of women, children and minorities,” he said.

No country has recognised the Taliban who took over Afghanistan in August 2021, after a 20-year insurgency against U.S.-led forces, with a speed and ease that took the world by surprise, following which President Ashraf Ghani fled the country.

Russia’s Sergei Lavrov said Moscow expected the Taliban leadership to “deliver on their promises to come up with an inclusive government”.

“The assurances that were given in regards of human rights, security in the territory of Afghanistan, and the eradication of terrorist threats, drug trafficking, we are keeping an eye on this,” Lavrov said.

Pakistan’s Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari said the situation in Afghanistan presents new challenges as well as opportunities.

“After being the playground for great powers, time and time again, we owe it to the people of Afghanistan to not repeat the mistakes of the past,” he said.

“A united international community must continue to urge the Afghan authorities to adopt universally accepted principles of political inclusivity, and respecting the rights of all Afghans, including girls’ right to education.”

Concerns over the stability of Afghanistan are growing as the country struggles with its economy and humanitarian crises under Taliban rule.

U.N. Secretary-General Antonio Guterres this week warned of a severe shortfall in financial pledges for its humanitarian appeal this year, which is just over 6% funded, short of the $4.6 billion requested for a country in which most of the population lives in poverty.

The Taliban have also tightened controls on women’s access to public life, including barring women from university and closing girls’ high schools.

The SCO is a political and security union of countries spanning much of Eurasia, including China, India, Pakistan and Russia, and is seen as a counterweight to Western influence in Eurasia.

The meeting in Goa is expected to finalise the expansion of the group to include Iran and Belarus.

It will also prepare the ground for an SCO summit in India in July that Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese counterpart Xi Jinping are expected to attend.

Reporting by Krishn Kaushik; Writing by YP Rajesh; Editing by Nick Macfie
India, Russia, Pakistan urge Taliban to respect rights of all Afghans
read more

Participants of SCO Meeting Urge Kabul to Ensure Inclusive Govt

Pakistan’s foreign minister Bilawal Bhutto Zardari said that ensuring peace in Afghanistan is the key to peace in the region and the world.

The foreign ministers of India, Russia and Pakistan on Friday called for a representative government in Afghanistan and the protection of women’s rights.

They were speaking at the day-long meeting of foreign ministers of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO) in the Indian coastal resort state of Goa, just ahead of a meeting scheduled over the weekend in Pakistan between the foreign ministers of Pakistan, China and Afghanistan.

Speaking at the meeting, Indian Foreign Minister Subrahmanyam Jaishankar said that “the unfolding situation in Afghanistan remains at the center of our attention. Our efforts should be directed towards the welfare of the Afghan people.”

“Our immediate priorities include providing humanitarian assistance, ensuring a truly inclusive and representative government, combating terrorism and drug trafficking, and preserving the rights of women, children and minorities,” Jaishankar said.

Russia’s Sergei Lavrov said Moscow expected the current Afghan government to “deliver on their promises to come up with an inclusive government”.

“The assurances that were given in regards of human rights, security in the territory of Afghanistan, and the eradication of terrorist threats, drug trafficking, we are keeping an eye on this,” Lavrov said.

Pakistan’s foreign minister Bilawal Bhutto Zardari said that ensuring peace in Afghanistan is the key to peace in the region and the world.

“A peaceful and stable Afghanistan is a key not only to regional integration and economic cooperation but also to global peace and stability,” Zardari said.

“The absence of the formation of an inclusive government will challenge Afghanistan’s stable security perspective in the future,” said Mehdi Manadi, a political analyst.

In reaction to this meeting, Suhail Shaheen, the head of the Islamic Emirate’s political office in Qatar, said that there should be discussion regarding the solution of the country’s present issues and the recognition of the Islamic Emirate in every meeting on Afghanistan.

“The current sanctions imposed on Afghanistan should be lifted, the foreign exchange reserves of the Afghanistan Bank should be returned, and the present government should be recognized,” Shaheen said.

China, Russia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan, Pakistan, and India are all permanent members of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO), whereas Afghanistan is a member as an observer.

Participants of SCO Meeting Urge Kabul to Ensure Inclusive Govt
read more

Work Suspension Ends for Afghan UN Employees in Country

The Ministry of Economy noted that UN can play a significant role in reducing poverty in Afghanistan.

From April 5 to May 5 the UN told its staff not to show up for work as a result of the restriction on female employees working in UN agencies in Afghanistan.

Farhan Haq, deputy spokesperson for the Secretary-General, told a press briefing that the results of the review of the suspension of the employees of this organization in Afghanistan will be made public once it is completed.

“At this stage, we’re waiting for the review to be completed.  And once that’s happened, we’ll be able to share what the results of that are. We’ll try to provide the information as quick as we get it.  I don’t know honestly when that will be.  We’re waiting for the results just like you are.  And once we have them, we’ll share them,” Farhan Haq said.

The United Nations has 23 offices in Afghanistan that operate in various sectors, including: The UN Assistant Mission in Afghanistan (UNAMA), Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), and the United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF).

“The United Nations is a bridge between Afghanistan and the rest of the world in addition to providing humanitarian aid,” said Tariq Farhadi, a political analyst.

The Ministry of Economy noted that UN can play a significant role in reducing poverty in Afghanistan.

“The United Nations can play a significant role in reducing poverty through humanitarian aid, but provided it is not influenced by big powers in the internal affairs of Afghanistan,” said Abdul Latif Nazari, deputy minister of economy.

In a press conference on Tuesday, UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres described the humanitarian situation in Afghanistan as “challenging” and noted that 6.4% of the assistance requested by the organization has been collected for Afghanistan.

Work Suspension Ends for Afghan UN Employees in Country
read more

US State Dept Spokesperson’s Remarks on Recognition of Islamic Emirate

Head of the Islamic Emirate’s Qatar based political office, Suhail Shaheen, said that the Islamic Emirate wants to be recognized by the international community

The US Department of State’s deputy spokesperson Vedant Patel said at a press briefing that there are several issues in Afghanistan that makes life challenging and difficult for the Afghan people and that need to be addressed before any kind of international engagement or recognition will take place with the current Afghan government.

“What Special Representative West was referring to was that there continue to persist a number of issues in Afghanistan that make – that the Afghan people – that makes life for the Afghan people challenging and difficult that need to be addressed prior to any kind of international engagement or recognition to take place as it relates to the Taliban,” Patel said.

Speaking at the press briefing, Patel said that some examples of these challenges are the “continued presence of terrorist organizations, the lack of inclusivity, especially as it relates to human rights – specifically human rights and its impact on women and girls. Many of these areas have been undermined recently by decisions by the Taliban.”

Meanwhile, the Germany in Afghanistan on Twitter said that the international community will not recognize the current Afghan government unless it moves on women’s rights and create an inclusive government.

“The International community stands united in its stance towards the DFA. No recognition unless the DFA moves on women‘s rights, inclusive government, unhindered humanitarian access and other issues!,” Germany in Afghanistan tweeted.

“One of the conditions for recognition of the present government of Afghanistan is that they respect human rights, address women’s rights, and provide a framework for all activities for women,” said Najibullah Shamal, a political analyst.

However, the head of the Islamic Emirate’s Qatar-based political office, Suhail Shaheen, said that the Islamic Emirate wants to be recognized by the international community.

“Sadly, some nations use sanctions on Afghanistan as a way to put pressure on the country, from which the people suffer. On the other hand, they are promoting human rights, which contradicts one another,” Shaheen noted.

Previously, the US special envoy for Afghanistan, Thomas West, referring to the Doha meeting, said the solution of the current challenges in Afghanistan is in political dialogue between Afghans.

US State Dept Spokesperson’s Remarks on Recognition of Islamic Emirate
read more

‘We can’t remain silent’: journalists refuse to give up despite Taliban terror

Ruchi Kumar

The Guardian

Thu 4 May 2023 05.00 EDT

Since the Taliban took over Afghanistan, one-third of journalists have left, while those who remain live with threats, attacks, unlawful detention and extortion

Mortaza Behboudi, an Afghan-French journalist, had been drawn back to Afghanistan, which he had left aged 21, to report on the deteriorating humanitarian conditions and situation for women.

“He has a passion to give voice to people who had their voices taken from them, which is why he went back to Afghanistan,” says Aleksandra Mostovaja, Behboudi’s wife.

“He felt it was so important that he should be there, not only because he knew the language, the history, its culture, but also because any story on Afghanistan without perspective of its people will not be complete.”

But on 7 January, two days after he had arrived in Kabul and before he could even begin his work, Behboudi, a French national of Afghan origin, was arrested by the Taliban. Mostovaja has spoken to him just once since – a short phone call in the presence of the Taliban – on 26 January.

“His voice sounded very bad, like he was about to cry and that has made me very worried [abut his condition]. The Taliban have not told us officially why he was arrested, but sources told us that he might be accused of spying, which just isn’t true,” she says.

Mostovaja believes his reporting may have been a reason for his detention. “Some journalists told us that they [the Taliban] make such arrests as a warning to others about what they can do to those who report against them,” she adds.

Since taking over Afghanistan in August 2021, the Taliban have repeatedly targeted journalists. Faced with threats to their lives and increasing restrictions on their work, particularly against women, many are being forced into exile. About one-third of Afghanistan’s journalists have since left the country, with 318 of the 623 media outlets registered in 33 Afghan provinces shutting down, according to one estimate last year.

Several journalists that spoke to the Guardian shared testimonies of threats, attacks, unlawful detention and extortion.

Attacks on journalists in Afghanistan are not limited to the Taliban. Mohammad Sahil*, a 28-year-old Afghan reporter, survived an Islamic State bomb attack in March at an event to honour local journalists at the Tebyan cultural centre in the northern Afghan city of Mazar-i-Sharif.

“Everything went dark, and I lost consciousness for a few minutes. When I opened my eyes, blood was flowing at the back of my neck and my eyes were filled with smoke and dirt. All my colleagues were lying broken and bloodied around me,” he says.

The attack claimed the lives of two Afghan journalists and injured dozens of others, including Sahil, who suffered severe damage to his ears. “I have been living in fear since then, changing locations every night. As a Hazara and a journalist, I am an Isis target,” he says, referring to the historically persecuted ethnic group in Afghanistan. “Sometimes I have no hope left that I will survive to have a future,” he adds.

Sahil says he had made several unsuccessful attempts to leave Afghanistan after the Taliban takeover. The Taliban had taken over his office and turned it into a religious school.

“After I lost my job, and facing security challenges for my work, I decided to go to Iran, hoping to apply for asylum to a European country from there,” he says. However, he was forced to return to Afghanistan after being unable to extend his visa in Iran.

Back in Afghanistan, he found work as a freelancer to support his family, but the attack has convinced him he needs to leave Afghanistan once again.

“Life in exile is extremely difficult, but I could be hurt and even killed in Afghanistan. The days pass with despair and they are darker than the darkest nights,” he says.

Even before the Taliban takeover, Ahmad Idrees*, a 38-year-old Afghan journalist, had faced threats from the insurgent group. Letters bearing Taliban insignia, delivered to his office and home in northern Afghanistan, would declare him an infidel and a traitor, with threats to punish him for his critical reporting of the group’s activities.

“When they finally took over, I started to receive incessant calls and messages on social media threatening to kill me and hurt my family. After months of hiding in different locations, I had no option but to escape the country,” he says.

Idrees is among an estimated 250,000 Afghans living in Pakistan, but even there he doesn’t feel safe. In February this year, he was arrested along with a colleague by the local police and forced to pay a bribe.

Several Afghans interviewed for this story confirmed that it is common for authorities in Iran and Pakistan to extort refugees. In January, more than 600 refugees in Pakistan were sent back to Afghanistan, leaving many exiles in constant fear for their lives and afraid to leave their homes.

Mostovaja has had little contact with her husband since the Taliban-monitored phone call three months ago. She says he had felt safe coming back to Afghanistan on a French passport.

“It is not possible to understand what is happening in Afghanistan without Afghan journalists. Which is why it is important to fight for their freedom of speech and expression. We can’t remain silent,” she says.

*Names have been changed to protect identities

‘We can’t remain silent’: journalists refuse to give up despite Taliban terror
read more