UN-led meeting in Qatar with Afghan Taliban is not a recognition of their government, official says

BY  RAHIM FAIEZ
Associates Press

ISLAMABAD (AP) — A United Nations-led meeting held in Qatar with the Taliban on increasing engagement with Afghanistan does not translate into a recognition of their government, a U.N. official said Monday.

The gathering on Sunday and Monday in Qatar’s capital of Doha with envoys from some two dozen countries was the first time that representatives of the Afghan Taliban administration attended such a U.N.-sponsored meeting.

The Taliban were not invited to the first meeting, and U.N. Secretary-General Antonio Guterres said they set unacceptable conditions for attending the second one, in February, including demands that Afghan civil society members be excluded from the talks and that the Taliban be treated as the country’s legitimate rulers.

Ahead of Doha, representatives of Afghan women were excluded from attending, paving the way for the Taliban to send their envoys — though the organizers insisted that demands for women’s rights would be raised.

“I would like to emphasize that this meeting and this process of engagement does not mean normalization or recognition,” Rosemary A. DiCarlo, a U.N. official for political and peacebuilding affairs said Monday.

“My hope is that the constructive exchanges on the various issues over the last two days have moved us a little closer to resolving some of the problems that are having such a devastating impact on the Afghan people,” she added.

Zabihullah Mujahid, chief Taliban government spokesman who headed the delegation to Doha, said there was opportunity for them to meet with representatives of various countries on the sidelines of the gathering.

He added that the messages from the Taliban “reached all participating” countries at the meeting. Afghanistan needs cooperation with the private sector and in the fight against drugs, he also said. “Most countries expressed their willingness to cooperate in these areas.”

The Taliban seized power in August 2021 as United States and NATO forces were in the final weeks of their pullout from Afghanistan following two decades of war. No country officially recognizes the Taliban and the U.N. has said that recognition remains practically impossible while bans on female education and employment remain in place.

However, some participants, including Canada, expressed disappointment over the exclusion of women and civil society representatives.

“Canada is extremely disappointed that the U.N. organizers have excluded non-Taliban Afghan participants, including women’s advocates, religious and ethnic minorities, and human rights groups from participating in the meeting’s main sessions,” David Sproule, Canada’s special representative for Afghanistan, said in a statement.

DiCarlo, the U.N. official, said that “while women and civil society were not sitting across the table form the de facto (Taliban) authorities in last two days, we made their voices heard … civil society has a rightful role to play in shaping Afghanistan’s future.”

 

UN-led meeting in Qatar with Afghan Taliban is not a recognition of their government, official says
read more

Taliban Talks With U.N. Go On Despite Alarm Over Exclusion of Women

Reporting from Kabul, Afghanistan

The New York Times

The meeting is the first between the Taliban and a United Nations-led conference of global envoys who are seeking to engage the Afghan government on critical issues.

Taliban officials attended a rare, United Nations-led conference of global envoys to Afghanistan on Sunday, the first such meeting Taliban representatives have agreed to engage in, after organizers said Afghan women would be excluded from the talks.

The two-day conference in Doha, Qatar, is the third of its kind. It is part of a United Nations-led effort, known as the “Doha process,” started in May 2023. It is meant to develop a unified approach for international engagement with Afghanistan. Envoys from around 25 countries and regional organizations, including the European Union, the United States, Russia and China, are attending.

Taliban officials were not invited to the first meeting and refused to attend the second meeting, held in February, after objecting to the inclusion of Afghan civil society groups that attended.

The conference has drawn a fierce backlash in recent days after U.N. officials announced that Afghan women would not participate in discussions with Taliban officials. Human rights groups and Afghan women’s groups have slammed the decision to exclude them as too severe a concession by the U.N. to persuade the Taliban to engage in the talks.

The decision to exclude women sets “a deeply damaging precedent” and risks “legitimatizing their gender-based institutional system of oppression,” Agnès Callamard, the secretary general of Amnesty International, said in a statement referring to the Taliban’s policies toward women. “The international community must adopt a clear and united stance: The rights of women and girls in Afghanistan are nonnegotiable.”

Since seizing power from the U.S.-backed government in 2021, Taliban authorities have systematically rolled back women’s rights, effectively erasing women from public life. Women and girls are barred from getting education beyond primary school and banned from most employment outside of education and health care, and they cannot travel significant distances without a male guardian.

Human rights monitors have described the government’s policies as akin to “gender apartheid” and suggested that the systematic oppression of women and girls could amount to crimes against humanity.

U.N. officials defended their decision to exclude Afghan women in the talks this week, insisting that the issue of women’s rights will be brought up in discussions with the Taliban. They also said that they will meet Afghan civil society representatives before and after the talks with Taliban officials.

“The issue of inclusive governance, women’s rights, human rights writ large, will be a part of every single session,” Rosemary DiCarlo, the U.N. political chief who is chairing the meeting, said in a news conference on Thursday.

Many Afghan women also called on Afghan activists invited to attend the side talks in Doha to boycott the discussions in protest.

The meeting represents an effort by the international community “to normalize the Taliban,” Rokhshana Rezai, an Afghan woman activist, posted on X. “I ask all those who believe in freedom and humanity to boycott this meeting, because this meeting is neither for the benefit of the Afghan people nor for the benefit of Afghan women.”

The controversy around the conference underscores the heated tensions within the West over how to deal with Afghanistan’s new government.

Some groups have pushed to isolate the Taliban by using sticks, like sanctions, over carrots to persuade them to change their most controversial policies toward women. Others have sought to engage the new government, in the hope that fostering more dialogue would bring policy changes within Afghanistan to make the government more palatable to the West.

Officials who are seeking to engage the Taliban want to focus on critical issues like counterterrorism, given the presence of terrorist groups, including the Islamic State affiliate in the region, on Afghan soil. They also say that without greater dialogue, Afghanistan could become more closely allied with Russia and China, both of which have been willing to overlook the Taliban’s human rights record in engaging with their government.

U.N. officials emphasized last week that the conference with Taliban officials did not represent a step toward formally recognizing the group as the legitimate rulers of Afghanistan. To date, no country has done so.

The chief spokesman for the Taliban, Zabihullah Mujahid, who is leading the delegation, said in a news conference on Saturday that his government hopes to discuss economic issues and international sanctions affecting Afghanistan.

The Taliban authorities “acknowledge the issues about women,” he said. “But these issues are Afghanistan’s issues,” he added, suggesting that the Afghan government did not believe the international community should be involved in setting its domestic policy regarding women’s rights.

Najim Rahim contributed reporting from San Francisco.

Taliban Talks With U.N. Go On Despite Alarm Over Exclusion of Women
read more

US and Qatar officials meet at Doha summit to support women in Afghanistan

Khaama Press

Rina Amiri, U.S. Special Representative for Afghanistan’s Women, met with Lulwa Al-Khater, Qatar’s Minister of State for International Cooperation, on the sidelines of the third Doha summit to discuss support for women and girls in Afghanistan.

Qatar’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs stated on Monday, July 1st, that the meeting emphasized the importance of economic stability and support for initiatives empowering women in Afghanistan.

The U.S. Special Representative for Afghan Women continues to express gratitude to Qatar for hosting the third Doha summit.

Ms. Amiri highlighted discussions at the Doha summit concerning the human rights situation of women and civil society in Afghanistan, as advocated by the United Nations.

She also previously mentioned meeting with Thomas West, the U.S. Special Representative for Afghanistan, emphasizing, “We will continue extensive negotiations during and after the third Doha summit to support a comprehensive framework for women and civil society. Ultimately, Afghanistan’s peace, security, and stability challenges cannot be resolved without their inclusion.”

The absence of women at the third Doha summit has also sparked reactions.

International stakeholders are urging inclusive dialogues prioritising Afghan women’s rights and participation in all aspects of the country’s reconstruction.

The outcomes of the third Doha summit will be pivotal in shaping international support for Afghanistan’s development, with a particular focus on gender equality and human rights.

Moving forward, continued engagement and advocacy are crucial to ensuring that Afghan women are integral to the peace and stability of their nation.

US and Qatar officials meet at Doha summit to support women in Afghanistan
read more

Canada’s Intl Affairs Agency Concerned With Absence of Women at Doha 3

Tolo News

1 July 2024

Some women’s rights activists in Afghanistan also believe that the presence of women representatives at the third Doha meeting was crucial.

Canada’s International Affairs Agency stated in a press release that it is disappointed with the absence of Afghan civil society and women’s representatives at the third Doha meeting on Afghanistan.

The agency highlighted the absence of a Canadian representative at the third Doha meeting and reiterated that Canada has always emphasized the necessity of comprehensive participation in such meetings.

“The full, equal and meaningful participation of Afghan women in the Doha meeting process is not only a core tenet of the Women, Peace and Security agenda, but fundamental to the achievement of a peaceful, stable and inclusive Afghanistan. None of the goals that Afghans are seeking to achieve are possible without the full participation of women,” the statement reads.

Some women’s rights activists in Afghanistan also believe that the presence of women representatives at the third Doha meeting was crucial.

“When decisions are made about women, their representatives should be present. It is an urgent need. The absence is regrettable,” said Alam Tab Amiri, a women’s rights activist.

“Today, the doors of schools and universities are closed, and restrictions on women are increasing daily. It would have been better if women had participated,” said Tafseer Siyahpoosh, another women’s rights activist.

However, Zabihullah Mujahid, head of the Islamic Emirate delegation at the third Doha meeting, stated that the issue of women in Afghanistan is an internal issue and efforts are ongoing to address the challenges in this regard.

“Internal issues should be left to Afghanistan. We understand our problems and the demands of our people, and we are trying to find solutions. However, countries should establish positive interactions with Afghanistan as a nation, which benefits all people. If, God forbid, restrictions continue, the first ones to suffer will be the people and women,” said Mujahid.

This comes as the G7 countries, representatives of various countries for Afghanistan, and women’s rights advocates have previously expressed concern about the absence of civil society and women’s representatives at the third Doha meeting on Afghanistan.

Canada’s Intl Affairs Agency Concerned With Absence of Women at Doha 3
read more

Around 115,000 Afghan Migrants Return from Pakistan, Iran

Haqqani added that cash and food supplies have been distributed to the returnees.

The Ministry of Refugees and Repatriation reported the return of approximately 115,000 migrants from Pakistan and Iran in the past month.

Abdul Mutalib Haqqani, spokesperson of the Ministry of Refugees and Repatriation, told TOLOnews that 98,000 of these migrants were returned from Iran.

Haqqani added that cash and food supplies have been distributed to the returnees.

The spokesperson for the Ministry of Refugees and Repatriation said: “In the past month, nearly 115,000 Afghan citizens have returned from Pakistan and Iran, some forcibly and some voluntarily.”

At the same time, a number of Afghan migrants in Pakistan and Iran told TOLOnews that living conditions for migrants in these countries are becoming increasingly difficult.

“Afghan migrants who come to Iran to meet their basic needs are facing problems due to the lack of work and government pressures,” said Sharifullah, an Afghan migrant in Iran.

“When the police inspect refugees on the streets, they do not respect their documents and refugees are frequently harassed and extorted,” said an Afghan migrant in Pakistan.

Meanwhile, some migrant rights activists called on international organizations working in the field of migration to pressure host countries to adhere to international laws in their treatment and deportation of migrants.

“Any kind of illegal treatment of migrants for their return should be within the framework of international laws and with respect for human dignity,” said Mohammad Khan Talebi, a migrant rights activist.

This comes as some Pakistani media outlets have reported that Islamabad has decided to intensify the process of deporting illegal migrants from the country once again.

Around 115,000 Afghan Migrants Return from Pakistan, Iran
read more

Mujahid at Doha 3 Urges Enhanced International Engagement

Tolo News

1 July 2024

Mujahid wrote on X that in a meeting with the Indonesian foreign minister, he emphasized strengthening relations between the two countries.

On the sidelines of the Doha 3 meeting, Zabihullah Mujahid, who leads the Islamic Emirate delegation, met with representatives from several countries to discuss Afghanistan issues.

Mujahid wrote on X that in a meeting with the Indonesian foreign minister, he emphasized strengthening relations between the two countries.

He added that in a meeting with the deputy and ambassador of the Kazakh Ministry of Foreign Affairs, they discussed expanding trade relations and maintaining diplomatic relations.

The Islamic Emirate delegation also met with the Norwegian representative, and Mujahid said that this country has a “constructive” view on Afghanistan.

Meanwhile, Zabihullah Mujahid, in his speech at the third Doha meeting, called for Western countries to engage with the Islamic Emirate.

Mujahid said: “Western countries should engage in a realistic and practical manner, just like regional countries.”

Mujahid said that Western countries, like regional countries, can remove obstacles to expanding relations with the Afghan government and move towards positive engagement.

Zabihullah Mujahid said that discussions on lifting banking sanctions and the cultivation of poppies would be held during the Doha meeting.

He called sanctions on the country’s banking system unfair.

Mujahid said that the foreign policy of the Islamic Emirate is economy-focused and concentrates on expanding relations with countries through construction and regional projects.

“In the past two years, we have made good progress in the construction of the TAPI gas pipeline with Turkmenistan. We hope that with the implementation of this project, Afghanistan will play a positive role in the exchange and connection of energy between Central and South Asia,” he said.

The second day of the Doha 3 meeting began today (Monday, July 1) in Doha, the capital of Qatar, and discussions are set to take place regarding the prevention of drug cultivation and support for Afghanistan’s private sector.

Mujahid at Doha 3 Urges Enhanced International Engagement
read more

Overview of the First and Second Doha Meetings on Afghanistan

Tolo News

1 July 2024

Before this meeting, France24 reported, citing its sources, that the Doha meeting would review the UN’s humanitarian operations in Afghanistan.

The first Doha meeting was held in May 2023, and the second in February 2024.

The UN Secretary-General, Antonio Guterres, attempted to address the challenges and concerns of the Afghan people, including girls’ education, women’s work, and their basic rights in society, the Islamic Emirate’s commitments to the international community, and other issues, in the first Doha meeting. However, this meeting concluded without the presence of the Islamic Emirate delegation.

Before this meeting, France24 reported, citing its sources, that the Doha meeting would review the UN’s humanitarian operations in Afghanistan.

In its report, France24 said: “Antonio Guterres, the UN Secretary-General, is gathering international representatives on Monday in a closed location in Doha to find ways to influence the rulers of Afghanistan (Taliban). Guterres’s problem with the Taliban government’s action to prevent girls from going to school and women from working, even for UN programs, has deepened.”

However, this meeting did not result in solving the challenges of the Afghan people and was not considered the last meeting.

The second Doha meeting on the situation in Afghanistan and global concerns was held on the 18th and 19th of February 2024 in Doha, pursuing the following objectives:

  • Consultation on Afghanistan
  • Increasing international participation in a coherent and structured manner
  • Appointing a special UN representative for Afghanistan
  • Identifying fundamental characteristics for constructive and principled engagement
  • Global concerns about the policies of the Islamic Emirate

Moeen Gul Samkanai, a political analyst, told TOLOnews about the Doha meetings: “The first meeting, where the Islamic Emirate delegation was not invited, has a separate significance. In the second meeting, when they were invited but did not participate due to certain considerations, this is the difference. The third meeting, where delegations were practically invited and the meeting was held, is the distinction. In future meetings, political, cultural, and diplomatic issues may have a significant impact.”

Although the Islamic Emirate delegation was officially invited to the second Doha meeting, the interim government refrained from attending due to their demands not being accepted.

Antonio Guterres, at the end of the second Doha meeting on the 19th of February 2024, said: “In fact, I received a letter with a set of conditions to be present in this meeting that were not acceptable. These conditions first of all denied us to talk to other representative of the Afghan society and demanded a treatment that would to a large extent be similar to recognition.”

“The value of these meetings is significant because the countries that had years of invasion and interference in Afghanistan have come together and want to make a serious decision in determining the future fate of Afghanistan,” said Aziz Stanikzai, a political analyst.

Now, it remains to be seen what the outcome of the third Doha meeting will be for Afghanistan.

Overview of the First and Second Doha Meetings on Afghanistan
read more

Mujahid: Islamic Emirate Attending Doha Meeting to Foster Engagement

By Fidel Rahmati

Reports from the venue of the third Doha meeting in Qatar indicate that Roza Otunbayeva, head of the UN body for Afghanistan, Thomas Nicholson, and Asif Durrani, special representatives of the European Union and Pakistan, arrived in Doha today, Saturday, June 29th.

The third Doha meeting will be hosted by Rosemary DiCarlo, UN Deputy Secretary-General, in the Qatari capital on Monday and Tuesday, June 30th and July 1st.

Ms. DiCarlo has not yet arrived in Doha, but a UN spokesperson confirmed her travel to Qatar.

The presence of Roza Otunbayeva Mark Poots, the head and deputy political head of UNAMA, respectively, at the venue of the Doha meeting, has been confirmed, along with special envoys from the European Union and Pakistan arriving for Afghanistan.

Representatives from over 20 countries and delegates from several international organizations are participating in the second session of Doha, and a delegation from the Taliban will also be present at this conference.

Civil society and women representatives of Afghanistan, who have been key players in other international conferences on Afghanistan, have not been invited to the third Doha meeting, sparking widespread domestic and international criticism.

According to the UN rapporteur and other international observers, critics argue that excluding women and civil society from the Doha talks will come at a high cost.

Mujahid: Islamic Emirate Attending Doha Meeting to Foster Engagement
read more

Mujahid: Islamic Emirate Attending Doha Meeting to Foster Engagement

Mujahid stated that the Islamic Emirate’s participation in this meeting does not signify hostility towards any party.

Zabihullah Mujahid, the spokesperson for the Islamic Emirate, announced in a press conference that the Islamic Emirate will participate in the third Doha meeting with the aim of “engaging with all parties and resolving issues.”

Mujahid stated that the Islamic Emirate’s participation in this meeting does not signify hostility towards any party.

According to Mujahid, the Islamic Emirate invites the countries participating in the Doha meeting to engage with Afghanistan.

The spokesperson for the Islamic Emirate said: “Our participation in this meeting is not enmity towards any party but engagement with all parties, which should be understood and utilized better.”

Mujahid called on the countries participating in the third Doha meeting not to leave Afghanistan alone in difficult conditions.

Zabihullah Mujahid clarified that domestic issues of Afghanistan will not be discussed in the third Doha meeting because, in his opinion, Afghanistan’s domestic issues are related to the country, not the United Nations.

The spokesperson for the Islamic Emirate said that economic issues, restrictions, and achievements of the Islamic Emirate will be discussed in the third Doha meeting.

Mujahid said they are participating in this meeting based on conditions, but he did not provide further details on the matter.

He also commented on the Islamic Emirate’s opposition to the presence of women in the Doha meeting, stating that this opposition was to maintain Afghanistan’s unified stance in the meeting.

In part of his remarks, the spokesperson for the Islamic Emirate recounted the Eid message from the leader of the Islamic Emirate, which emphasized avoiding conflict, as an advisory message.

Mujahid, denying any conflicts within the Islamic Emirate’s system, said that the leader’s emphasis on avoiding conflicts does not indicate the presence of discord and conflict within their Islamic system.

The spokesperson for the Islamic Emirate stated: “The issue of women’s participation in this meeting was that no one other than the Islamic Emirate, which is a system, should represent Afghanistan, because if Afghans appear through several channels in external meetings, it means we are still scattered and our nation is not on one path, and it paves the way for external interventions. Therefore, it is better that whatever we do inside the country is among ourselves, but outside, we should be united as a single Afghan.”

Sheikh Hibatullah Akhundzada, the leader of the Islamic Emirate, in a recording for his Eid al-Adha sermon at the Eidgah Mosque in Kandahar, asked all the people of Afghanistan to set aside their differences.

The third Doha meeting is scheduled to be held on the 30th of June in Qatar.

Mujahid: Islamic Emirate Attending Doha Meeting to Foster Engagement
read more

‘No dialogue’: Pakistan says open to attacks on Afghan-based armed groups

By

Al Jazeera

Islamabad, Pakistan — Pakistan’s Defence Minister Khawaja Asif has warned that the country would not hesitate to launch attacks on the territory of Afghanistan, its neighbour, amid rising tensions between the two over security concerns.

When asked whether Pakistan would consider cross-border attacks to control perpetrators, the Asif replied to an interviewer, “If the need arises, there is nothing more important than Pakistan’s sovereignty.”

Addressing the legality of potential cross-border attacks, Asif argued that Pakistan must prioritise its own interests. “It is also a violation of international norms when Afghan soil is used to export terrorism, with those responsible receiving protection and safe havens by the people there,” he added.

In the interview on Thursday, he also rejected the prospects of any dialogue with the Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP), also known as the Pakistan Taliban, an armed group accused by Pakistan of launching attacks from across the border.

“There is no chance of a dialogue with them. What do we talk about, we need to have a common ground to speak to them,” Asif said.

The interview follows Pakistan’s recent announcement of a renewed military operation named Azm-e-Istehkam, aimed at curbing escalating violence since November 2022, when the TTP unilaterally ended a ceasefire.

Founded in 2007 and aligned ideologically with the Afghan Taliban, the TTP is an armed group advocating for the reversal of the merger of Pakistan’s northwestern tribal regions with Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province, and stricter enforcement of their interpretation of Islamic laws in the region.

Pakistan has repeatedly accused armed groups of launching attacks from Afghanistan, where it says the ruling Afghan Taliban, in power since August 2021, provides them with a safe haven. The Taliban denies these allegations.

Relations between the two neighbours have deteriorated significantly in the past two years, with numerous border skirmishes that have often led to closures of border crossings.

In March this year, Pakistan conducted air strikes inside Afghan territory in retaliation for attacks that resulted in the deaths of seven soldiers in Pakistan’s North Waziristan district in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province.

The Afghan interim government claimed that Pakistan targeted ordinary Afghan homes and condemned what it termed as its neighbour’s reckless actions.

Yet, even as Asif’s comments underscored the taut ties between the neighbours, Pakistan has insisted that it is not shutting the door on Afghanistan – and is keen to remain engaged in its neighbour’s future.

Pakistan’s Foreign Minister Ishaq Dar said on June 27 in the National Assembly that the country would send a delegation to attend United Nations-hosted talks with the Afghan Taliban in Qatar’s capital, Doha, on June 30.

Pakistan Taliban talks
Khwaja Asif visited Kabul with a high-level Pakistani delegation in February 2023 [Handout: The office of Deputy Prime Minister for Economic Affairs]

Dar, who also serves as the country’s deputy prime minister, added that the foreign office is planning a future visit by officials to Kabul.

“Afghanistan remains a top priority on our agenda. Make no mistake, Afghanistan has not been ignored by this government,” he emphasised.

However, Riccardo Valle, a researcher based in Venice with The Khorasan Diary – a non-partisan platform run by journalists – said that while improving the country’s security situation was necessary, the Azm-e-Istehkam operation could have negative consequences for Pakistan’s relations with the Afghan Taliban and may not achieve the goal of reducing violence.

“Pakistan has previously conducted air strikes, reportedly targeting TTP militants’ camps. These actions not only failed to weaken the group but also triggered strong propaganda responses from the TTP,” Valle told Al Jazeera.

Pakistan has witnessed a surge in violence over the past 18 months, with data showing more than 700 attacks in 2023 alone, resulting in nearly 1,000 deaths, primarily among law enforcement personnel.

The government has dispatched numerous delegations to Kabul, including a high-level visit by Asif and Pakistan’s intelligence chief, General Nadeem Anjum, in February 2023, yet mutual distrust between the two nations persists.

Valle notes the close relationship and shared ideology between the TTP and the ruling Afghan Taliban, making it challenging to envision a scenario where the Afghan Taliban would crack down on the Pakistan Taliban.

The researcher pointed out that the announcement of Operation Azm-e-Istehkam had already stoked fierce resistance from residents and political parties in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa.

“Today in Afghanistan, there exists a regime maintaining ties with the Pakistani Taliban. By launching this operation, Pakistan risks fostering further grievances in the province towards the state, potentially aiding the TTP,” he said.

SOURCE: AL JAZEERA
‘No dialogue’: Pakistan says open to attacks on Afghan-based armed groups
read more