‘They do not teach us what we need’: Inside the expansion of religious schools for girls across Afghanistan

Story by Isobel Yeung and Mick Krever

Girls study at a religious school, or madrasa, where the curriculum is largely set by the Taliban government and devoted to Islamic studies.

EDITOR’S NOTE:  This story is part of As Equals, CNN’s ongoing series on gender inequality. For information about how the series is funded and more, check out our FAQs.

Kabul, Afghanistan — 

“I want” – the girl stops herself – “I wanted to be a doctor in the future. But when the Taliban came to Afghanistan, all the doors of schools were closed.”

Inside the Taliban-approved Naji-e-Bashra madrasa – a girls-only religious school on the outskirts of Kabul – a teenage girl wearing a full face covering speaks nervously. Her classmate grabs her arm beneath the table, aware that any criticism of the ruling Taliban government is ill-advised.

Imperfect though these religious institutions are, they are the only option for most Afghan girls over the age of 12 who want any education. Afghanistan remains the only country in the world that prohibits girls and women from getting general education at secondary and higher levels.

In July this year, the International Criminal Court sought arrest warrants for two of the top Taliban leaders, citing the persecution of women and girls as evidence of crimes against humanity. The Taliban denounced the court as showing “enmity and hatred for the pure religion of Islam.”

The Taliban had originally stated that the suspension of female education would be temporary, and some leaders said that they wanted mainstream schools to reopen once security issues were resolved. But four years on, the fundamentalist wing of the Taliban seems to be winning. Non-religious schools, universities and even healthcare training centers remain closed off to half the population. According to a report published in March by UNESCO, a United Nations agency, nearly 1.5 million girls have been prohibited from attending secondary school since 2021.

Meanwhile, the number of madrasas educating girls and boys across Afghanistan has grown sharply. According to data from the Ministry of Education, 22,972 state-funded madrasas have been established over the past three years.

At the Naji-e-Bashra madrasa, where CNN gained rare access to film in recent weeks, enrolment has skyrocketed since the Taliban began depriving girls of a “mainstream” education.

Because this is a private facility, funded by parents of students who generally live a more privileged life, staff are given slightly more leeway to also teach languages and science alongside Islamic studies. In public madrasas, which are funded by the Taliban government, the curriculum is almost entirely religious in content.

In 2022, the Taliban announced their plans for the school curriculum, setting out many changes that according to a report by the Afghanistan Human Rights Center, a human rights monitoring group, “not only fail to meet the human development goals of international human rights instruments, but also teach students content that promotes violence, opposes the culture of tolerance, peace, reconciliation, and human rights values.”

The report published last December alleges that the Taliban has “tailored educational goals to align with its extremist and violent ideology.” It says that they have amended history, geography and religious textbooks and prohibited the teaching of concepts such as democracy, women’s rights and human rights.

“The students are very happy with our environment, our curriculum, and us,” says the principal of the Naji-e-Bashra madrasa, Shafiullah Dilawar, a self-declared long-time supporter of the Taliban. “The curriculum that is set in the madrasa is set in a way that it is very beneficial for the role of mothers in society, so they can raise good children.”

He denied any suggestion that such institutions were being used to further the Taliban’s ideological goals.

The Taliban rejected multiple requests for an interview.

Secret schools

But many girls and women in Afghanistan consider madrasas no substitute for the education they were increasingly able to access over the two decades preceding the chaotic US withdrawal in 2021.

Nargis is the model student. She’s conscientious, organized, hardworking and studied diligently throughout her life.

At the time that US troops were withdrawing from her city, Nargis was studying economics at a private university. She’d go to classes in the morning, work a part-time job in the afternoon, then teach herself English in the evening. She’d never tire of learning.

“If four years ago you asked me what I wanted to do with my life, I had lots of goals, dreams, and hopes,” she said wistfully. “At that time, I wanted to be a very big businesswoman. I wanted to import from other countries. I wanted to have a big school for girls. I wanted to go to Oxford University. Maybe I’d have my own coffee shop.”

But what broke her heart was seeing the faces of her younger sisters, at the time 11 and 12 years old, who came home one day and told her their school had been closed.

Nargis began collecting all her past textbooks and started teaching the girls everything she’d learned. Other relatives and neighbors began asking for help too – and she found it difficult to say no.

And so, every morning at 6 a.m. sharp, before the Taliban security guards have arisen, around 45 female students from as young as age 12 sneak across the city to Nargis’s family home. Nargis has no support or funding – and often the girls huddle around one textbook, sharing notepads and pens.

Together, they learn mathematics, science, computing and English. Nargis racks her brain for all the knowledge she’s ever accumulated and imparts it to her students.

When the time comes for them to return home, she worries endlessly.

Two months ago, members of the Taliban came to raid the home she was teaching from. She spent a night in jail and was reprimanded for her work. Her father and other male family members begged her to stop, telling her it was not worth it. But terrified though Nargis is, she says she refuses to abandon her students. She switched locations and carried on.

Up until earlier this year, USAID (the United States’ Agency for International Development) had been funding secret schools across the country – known as “community-based education” – as well as study abroad programs and online scholarships. With the cancellation of $1.7 billion worth of aid contracts (of which $500 million was yet to be disbursed) under the Trump administration, several of those educational programs are now winding down.

Nargis herself had been a beneficiary of one such program, studying online for a Bachelor of Business Administration at a US-funded program. Last month, she says, that program was cancelled. It was the nail in the coffin for Nargis’s ambitions. Not just the cancellation of her studies, but “the cancellation of my hopes and dreams.”

“My mum was never educated. She always told us how it was under the previous Taliban government, and so we studied hard… But what is the difference between me and my mum now?” she asked. “I have an education, but we are both at home.

“For what are we trying so hard? For what job and what future?”

‘They do not teach us what we need’: Inside the expansion of religious schools for girls across Afghanistan
read more

Travel influencers boost tourism to Taliban-run Afghanistan

By Astha Rajvanshi

NBC News

August 5, 2025

The influencers gain attention by gushing over visits to the Central Asian nation, although one critic notes that their trips legitimize its “gender apartheid.”

The influencers gain attention by gushing over visits to the Central Asian nation, although one critic notes that their trips legitimize its “gender apartheid.”
Margaritta, a 33-year-old travel influencer from Germany, embarked on a three-month solo trip through Afghanistan in May 2024. Despite a “media echo that Afghanistan was not safe,” she said, “I was not scared.”

She “felt fantastic,” Margaritta, who asked that only her first name be used for security reasons, told NBC News. “I was treated like a queen.”

The trip was “one of those amazing experiences that also pushed me,” she added in a post on her TikTok channel, @margarittasworld, which has over 18,000 subscribers.

Margaritta is among a handful of travel influencers who have gone to Afghanistan since the Taliban took power following a chaotic withdrawal of U.S.-led forces in 2021.

They are seen exploring the country’s landlocked, mountainous terrain and its tribal culture in videos posted online, contesting perceptions that the country is unsafe and hostile to women. While thrilling for the influencers and their followers, critics accuse these carefully edited travelogues of whitewashing the harsh realities of life in Afghanistan, particularly for women, and rehabilitating the country’s autocratic rulers.

Internationally renowned Afghan activist and scholar Orzala Nemat, currently a visiting fellow at the London-based think tank Royal United Services Institute (RUSI), said that the surge of foreign influencers in Afghanistan was deeply concerning.

“What we’re seeing instead is a curated, sanitized version of the country that conveniently erases the brutal realities faced by Afghan women under Taliban rule,” Orzala told NBC News.

The Taliban has effectively barred Afghan women from many aspects of public life, including access to education and jobs. In July, the International Criminal Court issued arrest warrants for two of the Taliban’s top leaders, accusing them of persecuting women and girls in Afghanistan, which the group dismissed.

Influencers continue to go to Afghanistan despite clear warnings from the U.S. State Department that Americans should not travel to the country “for any reason” and that “there is a risk of wrongful detention of U.S. nationals.”

The European Union and Britain have issued similar travel advisories, while none of these countries have operational embassies in Afghanistan, limiting the provision of consular assistance to citizens.

Margaritta traveled solo through Afghanistan for three months.

Margaritta, while acknowledging that the Taliban had imposed strict laws on women, said she viewed them instead as a sign that “women have value, and they are valued as precious.”

Her comments were echoed by 31-year-old Zoe Stephens, a British travel vlogger and tour guide from Liverpool, England, who has visited Afghanistan three times.

“All we see of the women in Afghanistan is shapes behind burqas,” she told NBC News. “But when I got there, I realized that … there’s a lot more nuance to it.”

Having spent time with some Afghan women behind closed doors, she added that much of this was not on video or photographed because “it’s very private.”

Stephens regularly shares her experiences in Afghanistan and North Korea, the other destination covered by her travel company Koryo Tours, with over 70,000 followers on her Instagram accounts, @zoediscovers and @zoediscoversnk.

Like Margaritta, Stephens said that during her time there, she saw that “the strength of the Afghan women is that they don’t have to just show it.”

In one of her posts, Stephens appears dressed in a headscarf and an abaya, a traditional robe, as she holds a selfie stick on a tour bus as it zooms through rugged landscape. The video cuts to show her laughing with local Afghan women as she explores lakes, mosques and mountain trails.

Her caption reads: “It might surprise you to hear that travelling Afghanistan as a woman is actually often safer than travelling as a man. Why? The things to watch out for in Afghanistan is not the government and what it controls; rather, what it can’t control.”

Still, Stephens then lists a few safety tips for women that include dressing appropriately, exuding modesty, avoiding crowded spaces and not making one’s location public in real time.

Margaritta says she was “treated like a queen” in Afghanistan.

Orzala, of RUSI, said that while influencers with Western passports “roam freely, pose for photos and gain online fame,” those privileges are denied to Afghan women, who are barred from schools, jobs or even walking freely in public without being accompanied by male guardians.

There are also moral and ethical dilemmas, she added, because profits from tourism risk indirectly legitimizing and financially sustaining a regime that has institutionalized “gender apartheid.”

As for videos from influencers that show Afghan women smiling in the background, Orzala said, “This should never be confused with contentment or consent to the current reality.”

“This is not cultural exchange; it’s neocolonial tourism dressed up as adventure,” she added.

Visitors to Afghanistan are still in the low thousands as the war-torn country tries to rebuild its image under strict Taliban-run Islamic laws and customs. Nearly 9,000 foreigners visited in 2024, while nearly 3,000 visited in the first three months of this year, according to a report from The Associated Press.

Along with travel influencers, some tourism companies are creating jaw-dropping videos that have since been reshared by Taliban accounts on social media in a bid to attract more visitors.

One outlandish 50-second video made by vlogger Yosaf Aryubi begins with an eerie scene of three people with bags over their heads, presumed to be held hostage by the men standing behind them, who are dressed like the Taliban with rifles slung over their shoulders.

“We have one message for America,” one of the armed men says, before pulling the bag off one of the hostages, only to reveal a grinning tourist who gives a thumbs-up and says, “Welcome to Afghanistan!”

The video then cuts to male tourists diving into scenic lakes and walking through waterfalls and even holding M4 rifles that are revealed to be replicas.

Not every influencer sees Afghanistan in that way. In another video, YouTuber Nolan Saumure, whose channel Seal on Tour has 650,000 subscribers, acknowledges that he only interacted with men during his trip there.

In a 35-minute video titled “Afghanistan Has Too Much Testosterone,” Saumure spins the camera around to show a large crowd of Afghan men swarming him.

“It’s a complete sausage fest in here,” he says.

Astha Rajvanshi is a reporter for NBC News Digital, based in London. Previously, she worked as a staff writer covering international news for TIME.

Caroline Radnofsky and Jay Ganglani contributed.

Travel influencers boost tourism to Taliban-run Afghanistan
read more

Afghanistan’s Healthcare System Near Collapse Amid Aid Cuts and Facility Closures

Afghanistan’s healthcare system nears collapse as aid cuts force closure of 425 facilities, leaving 23 million people in urgent need of food, clean water, and medical care.

Afghanistan’s healthcare system is on the verge of collapse following the Taliban’s return to power, as international aid, once the backbone of medical services, has been almost entirely cut off.

The U.S.-based New Lines newspaper reported on Thursday, August 14, that more than 23 million people, nearly half of the population, now need assistance to access food, clean water, or basic healthcare.

This crisis has deepened significantly since the withdrawal of most foreign aid and the exit of international relief agencies, leaving millions without reliable access to medical treatment.

According to the World Health Organization, over 425 health facilities have shut down, forcing many patients to travel for hours to reach the nearest functioning hospital or clinic.

Despite the end of large-scale fighting, hospitals remain in a state of emergency. Doctors say they now treat injuries from domestic violence, stabbings, and road accidents, along with medical complications caused by the lack of primary healthcare.

Health experts warn that without a rapid restoration of international funding and supplies, the country faces a complete breakdown of its health system, leading to a sharp rise in preventable deaths.

Aid organizations are urging the global community to act immediately, stressing that Afghanistan’s health crisis is now as severe as it was during the height of the war.

Afghanistan’s Healthcare System Near Collapse Amid Aid Cuts and Facility Closures
read more

Hundreds of Afghans in Pakistan Arrested and Deported After Germany Halts Resettlement Program

Advertisement

Around 400 Afghans awaiting relocation to Germany have been arrested in Pakistan, with several deported to Taliban-controlled Afghanistan, sparking urgent calls from rights groups to halt removals and resume transfers.

Hundreds of Afghans awaiting relocation to Germany have been arrested in Pakistan following Berlin’s suspension of its resettlement program for vulnerable Afghans. Humanitarian groups warn that some detainees have already been deported to Afghanistan.

According to a Politico report on Thursday, August 14, Pakistani authorities have detained around 400 Afghans in recent weeks, with several forcibly returned. The arrests have intensified fears for those left stranded.

Germany’s decision to freeze the program, which was designed to relocate Afghans at risk under Taliban rule, has left more than 2,200 people in legal limbo in Pakistan. Among them are women’s rights defenders and members of the LGBTQ community who face severe persecution if returned.

Hundreds of Afghans in Pakistan Arrested and Deported After Germany Halts Resettlement Program
read more

August 15 Marked with Calls for Stability and Balance

The acting Minister of Foreign Affairs, Amir Khan Muttaqi, also stressed the Islamic Emirate’s balanced foreign policy during the event.

At a ceremony in Kabul marking the fourth anniversary of the Islamic Emirate’s return to power, the acting Minister of Interior described the preservation of the current system as vital.

Khalifa Sirajuddin Haqqani stated that some people fail to understand the nationwide security and the current state of the country, emphasizing that Afghanistan has always responded firmly to any aggression.

He added: “This security and current situation are intolerable for the enemies. Afghanistan is a land of sacred people who, throughout history, have never been subdued by invaders; and whenever an attempt was made, it was met with a strong response.”

The acting Interior Minister further said that, contrary to claims by some countries and organizations, the Islamic Emirate remains committed to the Doha Agreement, and currently, no threat emanates from Afghan soil to other countries.

He also said: “The current system, as it pledged in Doha, is committed to its obligations. Anyone who has issues with this system, our doors are open to them.”

The acting Minister of Foreign Affairs, Amir Khan Muttaqi, also stressed the Islamic Emirate’s balanced foreign policy during the event.

He said that Afghanistan is no longer a battleground for international rivalries, but has instead become a connecting point between nations.

“Balanced policy means that from now on, we will not become enemies with one country for the sake of another. Afghanistan will no longer be a field for negative rivalries, but a hub of connectivity and economic cooperation,” he added.

Deputy Administrative Chief of the Prime Minister’s Office, Abdul Salam Hanafi, emphasized that the Islamic Emirate does not interfere in the internal affairs of other countries and expects the same in return.

He said: “We never want to interfere in other countries’ internal affairs, and we expect the same from them.”

24th Asad marks the anniversary of the fall of the Republic and the return of the Islamic Emirate to power in Afghanistan.

In previous years, the Islamic Emirate had also commemorated this day with military parades at the Bagram Airbase.

August 15 Marked with Calls for Stability and Balance
read more

Achievements, Challenges As Fifth Year of Islamic Emirate Rule Begins

The fourth year of the Islamic Emirate’s rule was a year between consolidating power internally and seeking legitimacy externally.

The fifth year of the Islamic Emirate’s rule arrives as the caretaker government faced serious challenges in both domestic and foreign policy over the past year.

The fate of the constitution and the formation of a permanent cabinet remain unclear, while efforts for the recognition of this government also continued.

Despite these challenges, the Islamic Emirate managed to establish good relations with some countries in the world. Russia was the first country to officially recognize the caretaker government, a move widely welcomed by current officials.

Dmitry Zhirnov, Russia’s ambassador to Kabul, said: “This decision, which was made in principle by the President of Russia at the suggestion of the Foreign Minister, demonstrates our sincere desire to establish a full partnership with Afghanistan. More than 100 years ago, Russia was the first country to recognize Afghanistan’s independence. All this testifies to our friendly relations with the people of Afghanistan.”

Zabihullah Mujahid, spokesperson for the Islamic Emirate, also said: “We call on other countries to fulfill their responsibilities in developing relations with Afghanistan and to cooperate with Afghans in general. They should recognize the system and the government for stability, economic growth, connectivity, and the creation of interactions.”

Over the past four years, officials of the Islamic Emirate have consistently sought to expand diplomatic relations with countries in the region and the world.

Amir Khan Muttaqi, acting Minister of Foreign Affairs, said that in the past year, Afghanistan’s diplomatic missions in China, the UAE, Uzbekistan, Turkey, Russia, and Pakistan were upgraded to ambassador level, and diplomats were also appointed to Germany, Norway, India, and Indonesia.

The number of active political representations of the Islamic Emirate abroad reached more than 40, and the number of other countries’ representations in Kabul approached 20.

Muttaqi added: “Kazakhstan has promised to accept an ambassador of the Islamic Emirate, who will be introduced in the near future, and last year we appointed diplomats to four new countries.”

Over the past year, Kabul hosted senior officials from the United States, Iran, Pakistan, Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, Russia, the Republic of Tatarstan (Russia), as well as the head of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC). At the same time, more than twenty senior officials of the Islamic Emirate, including Mullah Abdul Ghani Baradar and Amir Khan Muttaqi, traveled to over twenty regional and extra-regional countries.

Muttaqi said: “In the past nearly four years, we have succeeded in ensuring nationwide security, ending the threats of Daesh and other disruptive elements, abolishing the feudal system and drug cultivation, and reducing administrative corruption to zero.”

The Islamic Emirate also took part in several regional meetings, including, for the first time, the Economic Cooperation Organization (ECO) meeting, the Russia security meeting, the Kazan Forum, the Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC), and the Termez Dialogue.

In June 2024, Kazakhstan became the first country to remove Islamic Emirate officials’ names from its list of terrorist groups. Then, Kyrgyzstan also removed the Islamic Emirate from its list of banned organizations. Subsequently, the Russian Supreme Court announced the suspension of the name “Taliban” from its list of banned organizations.

Zamir Kabulov, Russia’s special representative for Afghanistan, said: “This decision is an important step for all state institutions of the Russian Federation. Now, a major legal obstacle to the expansion of political, economic, and other official cooperation with the Afghan government has been removed. We will not stop here, and further measures are on the way.”

Abdul Salam Hanafi, Deputy Prime Minister for Administrative Affairs, said: “The statement issued yesterday by the President of Kazakhstan regarding the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan was a just and proper decision, and our request is that other neighboring and regional countries also take similar actions. We want good relations with everyone.”

Over the past year, three American citizens, Ryan Corbett, Phy Day Hall, and George Glezman, were also released from prison by the Islamic Emirate as a “goodwill gesture” toward the United States.

Faye Hall, released American citizen: “Mr. President, I voted for you twice. I’m so glad you’re in the office. It’s the new era and in this situation, I’m glad you’re the president. And thank you for bringing me home. And I’ve never been so proud to be an American citizen.”

The caretaker cabinet continued its work without a final decision on its status, but some changes were made in its composition; among them, Mawlawi Abdul Kabir, Deputy Political Prime Minister, was appointed as acting Minister of Refugees and Repatriation.

Zabihullah Mujahid said regarding this: “The reshuffle in the Deputy Prime Minister’s Office and the appointment of respected Mawlawi Abdul Kabir as acting Minister of Refugees is a normal process and has been done to improve affairs. This is not something new for Islamic Emirate officials.”

The fourth year of the Islamic Emirate’s rule was a year between consolidating power internally and seeking legitimacy externally.

On one hand, there was official recognition from Russia, upgrading relations with regional countries, and participation in international meetings; on the other, the continued uncertainty over the formation of a permanent cabinet and the fate of the constitution.

All this presents a dual picture of the year; the future, especially regarding the formation of a permanent government and achieving broad international recognition, remains shrouded in uncertainty.

Achievements, Challenges As Fifth Year of Islamic Emirate Rule Begins
read more

Kabul Citizens Celebrate 4th Anniversary of Islamic Emirate Rule

From the early hours of the morning, thousands of citizens holding Islamic Emirate flags paraded through various parts of Kabul.

Alongside the people, both civilian and military members of the Islamic Emirate also widely celebrated the fourth anniversary of the Islamic Emirate’s takeover in Afghanistan on the 24th of Asad in the solar calendar (August 15).

Basir Ahmad, a resident of Maidan Wardak, said: “I am very happy that after twenty years, we are celebrating the fourth anniversary of the Islamic Emirate’s rule, and we had been waiting for this day for a long time. I am so happy about this day that I wasn’t even this happy on Eid.”

Nasrullah Nasrat, a resident of Kabul, also said: “Our message to the international community is that the Islamic Emirate governs the entire country, so they should avoid political confrontation, recognize the Islamic Emirate, and support the Afghan nation.”

After noon, the celebration of the fourth anniversary of the Islamic Emirate in Kabul took on a different tone.

Aircraft of the Islamic Emirate’s Air Force appeared in the skies over Kabul with special maneuvers and conducted aerial color spraying in several parts of the capital.

Mohammad Nabi, a resident of Paktia, said: “Afghans have gathered together and feel happy. This is a very happy day.”

Ajmal, a resident of Kabul, also said: “On this day, Afghanistan was freed from the occupation of the United States and other Western countries.”

While some citizens see this year’s celebration of the 24th of Asad as a sign of national unity, others believe that such occasions should also be used to strengthen public participation and improve the government’s communication with the people.

Kabul Citizens Celebrate 4th Anniversary of Islamic Emirate Rule
read more

My family may be killed if deported, says son of Afghan caught in UK data breachand end four years of injustice and impunity

Azadeh Moshiri
Pakistan correspondent
Reporting from Islamabad
BBC News
15 Aug 2025

An Afghan man, whose details were accidentally leaked by the UK in a major data breach, has been detained in Pakistan for imminent deportation alongside several family members, his son told the BBC.

The BBC has seen documents which appear to confirm the man was part of Afghan special forces units who worked alongside British forces in Afghanistan, known as the Triples.

The threat of deportation comes as Pakistan continues its drive to remove what they say are “illegal foreign nationals” to their countries.

But the Afghan man’s son said their case is particularly urgent, as if they are deported to Afghanistan, he fears they will be killed because of his father’s Triples association.

The man and his family initially applied to the UK’s Afghan Relocations and Assistance Policy (ARAP) – which was set up to relocate and protect Afghans who worked with British forces or the UK government in Afghanistan – shortly after the Taliban returned to power in August 2021.

The family were in Pakistan waiting for a final decision on the application – which was endorsed by the Ministry of Defence last year – when Pakistani authorities came to take them away.

The man’s son, Rayan, whose name we are changing for his safety, told the BBC he avoided being rounded up after hiding in a hotel bathroom in the capital Islamabad with his wife and baby son as several of his family members were taken to a holding camp.

“Some of my family are just children, the youngest is only eight months old, we kept begging the police to leave them.”

His brother later called from the camp to say officials informed them they would be deported, Rayan added.

“My brother told me they were kept in a room with about 90 other people, and were then singled out by name and separated,” Rayan said. “I’m so scared they will suddenly be deported.”

Rayan explained the family had been in limbo in Pakistan since October 2024, when the family had their biometrics recorded.

But they are still waiting.

“We have just been waiting with no explanation. They kept telling us to wait, and now it is too late,” Rayan said.

A spokesperson for the Ministry of Defence said it does not comment on individual cases. “We remain fully committed to honouring our commitments to all eligible people who pass their relevant checks for relocation,” the statement added.

The situation is made more worrying by the fact the family’s details were among those of nearly 19,000 Afghans who had applied to resettle in the UK which were inadvertently leaked in February 2022. Families involved in the leak fear it has made them vulnerable.

Rayan is now terrified police will come back to detain him, his wife and their child next, and said he has been pleading with the British High Commission in Islamabad to be relocated to another hotel for protection.

Calvin Bailey, a Labour MP who worked alongside the Afghan Triples as an RAF commander, told the BBC’s Newsnight programme that the situation is “incredibly upsetting”. He said Rayan’s father and the Triples were “people that we need to help and we owe a duty to and we must ensure that they receive more than the minimum protection”.

Bailey went on to add that he hopes the government and the British High Commission is engaged behind the scenes, even though that work is not always public.

Pakistan’s Interior Minister, Talal Chaudry, told the BBC it “should ask the UK authorities why they are delaying these resettlements”.

“It’s already been years,” he said. “Do you really think they will give any leniency to Pakistani nationals who are overstaying in the UK?”

Since September 2023, the year Pakistan launched its “Illegal Foreigners’ Repatriation Plan”, 1,159,812 individuals have returned to Afghanistan, according to the United Nations migration agency.

The government has maintained its policy is aimed at all illegal foreign nationals.

About three million Afghans are living in Pakistan, according to the UN’s refugee agency – including around 600,000 people who came after the Taliban takeover in 2021. The UN estimates that half are undocumented.

The United Nations Refugee Agency (UNHCR) has called on Pakistan to “ensure that any return of Afghans to Afghanistan is voluntary, safe and dignified”.

Amid police raids and deportations this summer, UNHCR has urged the government “to apply measures to exempt Afghans with continued international protection needs from involuntary return”.

Additional reporting by Usman Zahid

My family may be killed if deported, says son of Afghan caught in UK data breachand end four years of injustice and impunity
read more

Men celebrate fourth anniversary of Taliban’s return to power in Afghanistan

Guardian staff and agencies

Fri 15 Aug 2025 

Thousands gathered for Kabul ‘flower showers’ while women, banned from the events, staged protests

Thousands of men gathered across Kabul on Friday to watch flowers being scattered from helicopters to mark the fourth anniversary of the Taliban’s return to power – a celebration that women were barred from attending.

Three of the six “flower shower” locations were already off-limits to women, who have been prohibited from entering parks and recreational areas since November 2022.

The Taliban seized Afghanistan on 15 August 2021 as the US and Nato withdrew their forces at the end of a two-decade war. Since then, they have imposed their interpretation of Islamic law on daily life, including sweeping restrictions on women and girls, based on edicts from their leader, Hibatullah Akhundzada.

Friday’s anniversary programme, which also included speeches from cabinet members, was only for men. An outdoor sports performance, initially expected to feature Afghan athletes, did not take place.

Rights groups, foreign governments and the UN have condemned the Taliban for their treatment of women and girls, who remain barred from many jobseducation beyond sixth grade and most public spaces.

Members of the United Afghan Women’s Movement for Freedom staged an indoor protest against Taliban rule on Friday in the north-eastern Takhar province.

“This day marked the beginning of a black domination that excluded women from work, education, and social life,” the movement said in a statement shared with Associated Press. “We, the protesting women, remember this day not as a memory, but as an open wound of history, a wound that has not yet healed. The fall of Afghanistan was not the fall of our will. We stand, even in the darkness.”

There was also an indoor protest in the Pakistani capital, Islamabad.

Afghan women held up signs that said “Forgiving the Taliban is an act of enmity against humanity” and “August 15th is a dark day.” They were fully veiled, except for their eyes, in the photographs.

Earlier in the day, the Taliban leader had said God would severely punish Afghans who were ungrateful for Islamic rule in the country, according to a statement.

Akhundzada, who is seldom seen in public, said in a statement that Afghans had endured hardships and made sacrifices for almost 50 years so that Islamic law, or sharia, could be established. Sharia had saved people from “corruption, oppression, usurpation, drugs, theft, robbery, and plunder”, he said.

“These are great divine blessings that our people should not forget and, during the commemoration of Victory Day, express great gratitude to Allah Almighty so that the blessings will increase,” Akhundzada said in comments shared on X.

“If, against God’s will, we fail to express gratitude for blessings and are ungrateful for them, we will be subjected to the severe punishment of Allah Almighty,” he said.

Last month, the international criminal court issued arrest warrants for Akhundzada and the chief justice, Abdul Hakim Haqqani, accusing them of crimes against humanity for the persecution of women and girls.

The ICC said there were “reasonable grounds to believe” they had ordered policies that deprived women and girls of “education, privacy and family life and the freedoms of movement, expression, thought, conscience and religion”.

This year’s anniversary celebrations are more muted than last year’s, when the Taliban staged a military parade at a US airbase, drawing anger from Donald Trump about the abandoned American hardware on display.

Afghanistan is also gripped by a humanitarian crisis made worse by the climate crisis, millions of Afghans expelled from Iran and Pakistan, and a sharp drop in donor funding.

Men celebrate fourth anniversary of Taliban’s return to power in Afghanistan
read more

Afghanistan is starting its fifth year of Taliban rule. Here are 5 things to know

By THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

The Taliban seized control of Afghanistan in 2021 for the second time. Since then, the former insurgents have consolidated their grip on power, excluded women and girls from public life, stamped out internal dissent and external challengers, and gained debut recognition as the country’s official government from Russia, a permanent member of the U.N. Security Council.

The Taliban govern through decrees, but Afghans have aspirations and needs that cannot be fulfilled through edicts and ideology.

Climate changean increasing population, and severe cuts to foreign aid will test the Taliban’s ability to lead and not just rule.

Here are five things to know about the Taliban as they start their fifth year in power:

Kandahar-based Hibatullah Akhundzada has led the Taliban from insurgency to authority since his appointment in 2016. But transition and status are peripheral to what he has wanted for the past 20 years: establishing an Islamic system.

Central to this vision was his ratification last year of the Propagation of Virtue and Prevention of Vice Law, which codifies many aspects of Afghan life, including who people can befriend.

In June, Akhundzada said the Taliban had fought and sacrificed themselves for the implementation of Islamic law. It was obligatory to follow the leadership’s commands and directives, he added, and everyone was required to act within the bounds of this obedience.

His supporters emphasize his superior religious authority to issue decrees. The higher education minister went one step further in April, equating criticism of Akhundzada with blasphemy and saying obedience to him was a divine order.

“He (the leader) decides what moves and what doesn’t move, what happens and what doesn’t,” said Ibraheem Bahiss, a senior analyst with Crisis Group’s Asia program.

The Taliban’s internal differences are buried deep

There were pockets within the Taliban that initially advocated lifting bans on women and girls, or at least modifying them, to allow greater global and financial engagement. Akhundzada and his circle withstood such pressure, however, and the Taliban government has emerged from its isolation to develop diplomatic ties and raise several billion dollars every year in tax revenues to keep the lights on.

Power brokers, like Interior Minister Sirajuddin Haqqani, have been weakened. Since November, Akhundzada has had direct control over Afghanistan’s weapons and military equipment, sidelining the Interior Ministry and the Defense Ministry, which is run by Mullah Mohammad Yaqoob, whose father founded the Taliban.

Haqqani, whose uncle was killed in a high-profile suicide attack last December, used to take swipes at the leadership. Not anymore. Haqqani, who heads a powerful network of his own, cannot start a fight with the Kandahar faction and win.

Political deputy Sher Abbas Stanikzai rebuked Akhundzada in January, stating the education bans had no basis in Islamic law, or Sharia. He left Afghanistan shortly afterwards and remains outside the country. He denies reports that he fled or faced arrest had he stayed.

Akhundzada has put Islamic law at the heart of his leadership, while also putting his leadership at the heart of its implementation.

“He’s made himself indispensable, and the entire movement is beholden to him,” Bahiss said.

There’s no sign of change for Afghan women and girls

Russia’s recognition of the Taliban sends a “deeply troubling” message, said Zahra Nader, the editor-in-chief of the Afghan women-led newsroom Zan Times. “It tells the Taliban they can continue to suppress women’s rights and commit systematic human rights violations without facing consequences. They are being rewarded for it. This move is a slap in the face to Afghan women.”

There is opposition to the Taliban’s policies, but people are fearful because no powerful alternative exists, she said. The Taliban “took the country by force and maintained control” through violence. Women took to Afghanistan’s streets in protest after the takeover, but these were met with retaliation.

“The absence of visible protest should not be mistaken for acceptance,” said Nader. “It reflects the extreme risks people face for dissent. The resistance is still there, quiet, private, and simmering, but public expression has been crushed through fear and force.”

The Taliban insist that women’s rights are protected. Nader says that, although there is “little faith” that the country’s rulers will change their policies, women are preparing themselves “emotionally and intellectually” for a future beyond the Taliban.

“That hope, that this brutality will not last forever, is what keeps many of them going. These women do not believe the regime will change its stance on women’s rights.”

Regional ties are transactional

It’s not trust or shared values that define the Taliban’s relationships.

Afghanistan borders six countries, many of which are trade partners and also balk at being lectured by the West on rights and freedoms. Landlocked Afghanistan is sandwiched between the Middle East, Central Asia, and South Asia, making it strategically located for energy-rich and energy-hungry nations.

The Taliban’s bilateral relations proceed on common ground: borders, water, transit, and security. Anti-migrant rhetoric, especially in Europe, could increase diplomatic engagement as political parties in the West seek to placate their supporters.

The UK-based International Institute for Strategic Studies said the Taliban’s broader diplomatic interactions were eroding the “non-recognition” approach of the West and ushering in “creeping normalization.”

The Taliban feel comfortable in the region and have found an acceptable way of operating, while the region has adjusted to their presence.

“What we’ve seen in the last four years is not real pressure (on the Taliban), but rather normalization and appeasement,” Nader said. “For those of us watching from inside and outside Afghanistan, this is not just political, it’s personal. It’s painful. It confirms our fear that the suffering of Afghan women is being sidelined in favor of political interests.”

The real test for the Taliban is yet to come

Until April, the U.S. was the largest donor to Afghanistan, where more than half of the population relies on aid to survive. But it terminated this emergency assistance due to concerns that the Taliban were benefiting from such aid.

Thousands of Afghans, including women, will lose their jobs as nongovernmental organizations and agencies scale back their work or shut down. The loss of jobs, contracts, and the shrinking humanitarian footprint also equate to a loss in revenue for the Taliban.

One U.N. agency said there were “reputational and staff security risks” where humanitarian agencies were forced to suspend operations due to reduced funding, causing grievances among communities, or after partners couldn’t pay suppliers or complete contracts. Aid officials warn that frustration and an increase in tensions will trigger spontaneous violence as people compete for resources and services.

The cuts coincide with the mass expulsions of Afghans from neighboring countries, swelling the population and the ranks of the unemployed while also halting the flow of inward remittances. The World Health Organization estimates the population will increase by 85% to 76.88 million by 2050. Afghanistan needs to give people food, shelter, and economic opportunities.

Thomas Ruttig, from the Afghanistan Analysts Network, recalled meeting a leading Taliban figure in a “completely rundown” office during the late 1990s. The Taliban fighter told him they could live under those circumstances, but foreigners couldn’t.

“What they also say is that Afghans can live under those circumstances, which, to an extent, is true,” said Ruttig. “They were forced to live under those circumstances and have learned how to cope.” Now their means of coping — houses, land, and some savings — are gone.

The Taliban took it for granted that they won the war with the help of Allah and the population, he explained. He added that, although the Taliban were a reflection of Afghans’ ambitions, they needed to open up and listen to people’s concerns.

“But they know the more they open up, the more they are questioned, and their rule might be undermined.”

The Taliban needed to think about whether they wanted to govern the country simply to rule it, said Ruttig. “Or do we want to rule this country to make Afghanistan a better place to live? That’s probably the big question in front of them.”

Afghanistan is starting its fifth year of Taliban rule. Here are 5 things to know
read more