Biden says he was told Kabul would hold for six months after US troops left

A copy of Joe Biden’s memoir Promise Me, America stands on a reflective table, with a blurred television image of Biden speaking against American flags in the background.
A copy of former US President Joe Biden’s newly released memoir, Promise Me, America, which includes a chapter reflecting on the US war, withdrawal, and collapse of the Afghan government in 2021. Photo: Khaama Press.

In his new memoir, the former US president says promises about the Afghan government and about security at Kabul airport turned out to be wrong. He still says he would make the same decision again.

Former US President Joe Biden says he was told that Kabul would stay under government control for at least six months after American troops left Afghanistan. It did not. The capital fell to the Taliban on August 15, 2021, more than two weeks before the last US troops departed.

In his new memoir, Biden writes that US military and intelligence officials gave him this assurance. They also told him the Afghan government could stand on its own. “This would prove not to be true,” he writes.

Biden also says he was given assurances about the safety of US troops, especially at the gates of Kabul airport. That assurance, he writes, also “would prove not to be true.” He does not say who gave it or what exactly it promised.

On August 26, 2021, a suicide bomber attacked the airport’s Abbey Gate. The blast killed 13 American service members and about 170 Afghan civilians.

Khaama Press reviewed a printed copy of the book, Promise Me, America, which went on sale on Tuesday. Biden writes about Afghanistan in Chapter Six, on pages 133 to 144. He defends his decision to end the war. “I would make the same decision again,” he writes.

A war he wanted to end in 2011

Biden says the United States should have left Afghanistan in 2011, after US forces killed al-Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden. “I believe we should have taken the opportunity to leave on the heels of eliminating bin Laden,” he writes.

He is also critical of the Afghan governments that Washington supported after 2001. He says they never won broad public support, and that “enormous sums of money disappeared into the hands of local officials.” He writes that the government never seemed legitimate in a society “dominated by clannish rival tribes.”

Biden calls the February 2020 deal between the Trump administration and the Taliban, signed in Doha, a “ticking time bomb.” Under that deal, the United States agreed to pull out its troops. Biden says Afghanistan’s government was “entirely excluded” from it.

He writes that Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin and General Mark Milley, then the top US military officer, were “both troubled by the implications of the decision.” He does not say what they advised him to do.

In September 2021, Milley and General Frank McKenzie told the US Senate that they had advised keeping about 2,500 troops in Afghanistan. A month earlier, Biden had told ABC News that no one had given him that advice “that I can recall.”

How Kabul fell

News reports from 2021 show how quickly the warnings changed. In June, US media reported an intelligence warning that the Afghan government could fall within six months of the US withdrawal. On July 8, Biden told reporters it was “highly unlikely” that the Taliban would take over the whole country. By August 11, US officials said Kabul could be cut off within 30 days and could fall within 90.

Biden writes that he spoke with Afghan President Ashraf Ghani by phone on July 23, 2021. He says Ghani “insisted that he and his troops were ready to defend their country.”

The memoir does not mention other parts of that call. A transcript reported by Reuters in September 2021 shows Ghani warned that his government was “facing a full-scale invasion.” It also shows Biden asked Ghani to present a more positive picture of the war, “whether it is true or not.”

Less than a month after the call, Ghani fled the country. Biden writes that “the Afghan army simply melted away.”

A US government watchdog, the Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction (SIGAR), studied why Afghan forces collapsed. In 2022, it found that the biggest single reason was the US decision, made under both Trump and Biden, to pull out American troops and the contractors who supported Afghan forces.

The day after Kabul fell, Biden spoke to the nation. He said he stood “squarely behind” his decision and admitted that events had moved “more quickly than we had anticipated.” He also said US troops should not die in a war that Afghan forces were “not willing to fight for themselves.”

Abbey Gate and those left behind

Biden says the Abbey Gate bombing killed 169 Afghan civilians and 13 US service members. A Pentagon investigation later put the Afghan death toll at no fewer than 170. It found that a single bomber from ISIS-K, the Afghan branch of the Islamic State group, carried out the attack. That investigation and a second review in 2024 both concluded that troops at the gate could not have prevented it.

Writing about the families of the Americans who died, Biden says: “I know some of those families will always hold me responsible for their loved ones’ deaths and never forgive me. I understand it and respect it.”

Biden calls the operation the largest evacuation airlift in history, with “more than 124,000 people” flown out. Pentagon figures show 124,334 people left on US and allied flights, including almost 6,000 Americans.

Many Afghans who had worked with Americans were left behind. In September 2021, a senior State Department official said most Afghans who had applied for special US visas had not been evacuated.

The chapter does not mention the US drone strike in Kabul on August 29, 2021. The Pentagon later admitted that the strike killed 10 civilians, including seven children. The chapter also does not discuss Afghan women and girls, or life under Taliban rule since 2021.

A State Department review in 2023 found that senior officials in both the Trump and Biden administrations did not plan enough for the worst outcomes. Biden writes: “I will accept and have always accepted full responsibility for the decision to leave.”

Biden says he was told Kabul would hold for six months after US troops left