Who Dares, Kills? Alleged war crimes and cover-ups by Britain’s special forces

British special forces are being investigated for war crimes allegedly committed between 2010 and 2013 in Afghanistan. A public inquiry is looking into the deaths of Afghans who were killed in suspicious circumstances, mostly involving detention operations that showed hallmarks of summary executions. The killings came to light because of whistle-blowers inside the military, combined with the tenacity of victims and investigative journalists. The scale of the alleged crimes is shocking – lawyers say there were more than 80 suspicious deaths in the time period of the inquiry – but for the families involved, the end may be years away, or may never come. In this themed report, Rachel Reid explores what is known about the killings and the failures of accountability, which resonate darkly with other incidents and with the behaviour of the ‘elite forces’ of other nations. The inquiry and the reporting around it raise questions about the true numbers of victims and the dangers of a culture of exceptionalism among special forces, which morphs easily into one of impunity. 

You can preview the report online and download it by clicking here or the download button below

The SAS occupy a special place in British culture, illustrated by the rule-bending bravado of their motto, “Who Dares Wins.” Yet, in recent years, this reputation has been tarnished by growing accusations of not just rule-bending but potential war crimes, including the suspicious deaths of detainees, mostly during night raids, primarily in Helmand province between 2010 and 2013. Lawyers representing victims’ families say that more than 80 were killed, including children.

The UK military police did try to investigate a number of the killings, but they met resistance from special forces and produced no real accountability for victims’ families. The victims’ lawyers forced a judicial review, which forced the Ministry of Defence to release incriminating documentation, which revealed deep concerns about the incidents inside the military. Investigative reporting by the BBC and others rang raised yet more suspicious deaths and internal military concerns. One former SAS member told the BBC that on some operations, “the troop would go into guest house type buildings and kill everyone there. … It’s not justified, killing people in their sleep.”

According to the laws of armed conflict, detainees cannot be killed, unless in self-defence. To give the appearance of acting within the law, special forces appear to have concocted stories of firefights and even planted weapons on victims. This casual disregard for Afghan lives and for the law is all the more disturbing given what has been learned over the years – including through AAN investigations – about the patchy intelligence that special forces relied upon, which suggests that at least some – or perhaps many of the detainees being killed were not Taliban, but civilians.

This report outlines the patterns of the suspicious deaths, the alleged cover-ups and the failed investigations. It will consider the factors that may have contributed to this bloody period, including wider abuses by special forces, with similar patterns by Australian special forces and reports of extrajudicial killings by United States and Afghan special forces. It will look at the somewhat limited hopes for justice for victims emanating from the public inquiry and beyond.

Edited by Kate Clark and Roxanna Shapour 

You can preview the report online and download it by clicking here or the download button below

Who Dares, Kills? Alleged war crimes and cover-ups by Britain’s special forces