Afghanistan’s Taliban leaders issued different messages for Eid. Experts say that shows tensions

BY RIAZAT BUTT
Associated Press

KARACHI, Pakistan (AP) — Messages by two influential Taliban leaders in Afghanistan this week showed tensions between hardliners and more moderate elements who want to scrap harsher policies and attract more outside support, experts said Thursday.

The messages for Eid al-Fitr marking the end of Ramadan were delivered by supreme leader Hibatullah Akhundzada, who defended the imposition of Islamic law and railed against the international community for its criticism, and Interior Minister Sirajuddin Haqqani, who called on the Taliban to be humble and avoid behaving in ways that make Afghans unhappy.

The Taliban seized power in 2021 amid the chaotic withdrawal of U.S. and NATO forces after two decades of war. Their rule, especially bans affecting women and girls, has triggered widespread condemnation and deepened their international isolation.

He issued the second in a rare public appearance on Wednesday at Eidgah Mosque in the Taliban heartland of Kandahar in the south. His Eid sermon, a half-hour address in Pashto, was more in keeping with the tone and content of his past fiery messages.

“If anyone has any issues with us, we are open to resolving them, but we will never compromise on our principles or Islam,” he said. “At the same time, we don’t expect Islam to be disrespected. I won’t even take a step away from Shariah (Islamic law). They (the international community) object to it, saying public stoning and amputation are against their laws and human rights. You expect us to follow your laws while imposing them on us.”

Akhundzada is almost never seen in public. There are no photos from his address, and his face was concealed from the thousands of worshipers.

“We know that after nearly half a century of problems and difficulties, we cannot easily and urgently expect the kind of life and possibilities we wish for, but the important thing is that the (Islamic) system and the whole nation are working to fulfill these wishes,” he said.

Michael Kugelman, director of the Wilson Center’s South Asia Institute, said Haqqani, by attempting to show a softer side, was looking to draw trust and support from a broader Afghan public aware of the Taliban’s “brutal form” of governance. But for Akhundzada, the Eid sermon was about consolidating support and loyalty in his circle.

The messages also had a global audience in mind. The Haqqani network seeks investment and aid from the international community, Kugelman said.

“Projecting a softer side is likely meant to make potential donors more comfortable. With the emir (Akhundzada) it’s about signalling that the Taliban’s social agenda, especially its abhorrent policies toward women, isn’t up for negotiation,” he said.

Pakistani journalist and author Ahmed Rashid, who has written several books about Afghanistan and the Taliban, said the two leaders were sending a strong message to the faithful that nothing has changed despite pressure from the West.

“There are clearly divisions within the Taliban but they’re holding together,” Rashid said. “There are moderate elements that want to see women educated, but they’re not in a strong position so they’re biding their time.”

Haqqani has previously spoken out against the Taliban’s leadership and decision-making process, drawing a rebuke from chief spokesman Zabihullah Mujahid.

But Haqqani didn’t overstep in his Eid message, according to Rashid. “He is on the periphery, but he is very popular. His support base is pushing him forward.”

The Taliban’s double messaging is also part of a skillful campaign to show they have influence and clout at home and abroad, he said: “They’re saying, ‘We can spread the word.’ They have done this with pride and conviction.”

No country recognizes the Taliban as the legitimate government of Afghanistan. But some important regional players, including China, Iran and Pakistan, have formal diplomatic relations with them.

 

Afghanistan’s Taliban leaders issued different messages for Eid. Experts say that shows tensions
read more

Turkish Airlines to resume operations in Afghanistan soon: Official

The Taliban’s Ministry of Transport and Aviation states that Turkish Airlines intends to resume its flights to Afghanistan soon.

The spokesperson for this ministry wrote on its social media platform X, that there are no technical or airport-related issues for the company to begin its flights.

Imamuddin Ahmadi stated that all facilities for foreign airlines are available at all Afghanistan airports.

Following the Taliban’s resurgence in Afghanistan, many foreign airlines, including Turkish Airlines, suspended their flights to the country.

However, in January last year, Emirates Airlines resumed its flights to Afghanistan. Still, due to passenger shortages and existing issues in Afghanistan, the flights of these companies show a considerable reduction.

It is said that difficulties in obtaining visas for Afghans, especially traders, are one of the reasons for the decrease in air travel.

During the early days of the Taliban’s rule in Afghanistan, the Taliban’s Civil Aviation Authority announced that 60 to 70 aircraft were passing through Afghanistan airspace every 24 hours.

This is while before the collapse of the previous government, according to official statistics, over 250 flights were operated daily from Afghanistan airspace.

Turkish Airlines to resume operations in Afghanistan soon: Official
read more

ISIS-K surging after US left Afghanistan: Former CENTCOM Commander

Former commander of US Central Command (CENTCOM), has said that with the Taliban gaining power, ISIS Khorasan has found conducive conditions for advancement.

According to Business Insider, prior to the Taliban’s takeover of Kabul, ISIS Khorasan’s activities were limited to Afghanistan with minimal penetration beyond its borders.

However, afterward, it found more expansion opportunities and took responsibility for attacks beyond Afghanistan’s borders, including a suicide attack on the anniversary ceremony of Qasem Soleimani in Iran and an attack on a concert hall in Moscow.

Joseph Votel, who oversaw military operations in the Middle East in 2010, told Business Insider, “It won’t take long for these organizations to increase their activities and become more capable.”

Business Insider wrote in its report that without the US military presence in Afghanistan, options to combat ISIS are relatively limited. The report added that while the White House has previously emphasized a strategy beyond targeting terrorists with drones, there seems to be little evidence of the effectiveness of such a strategy.

Business Insider noted that before the collapse of Afghanistan’s previous government, the US had significant intelligence capabilities in Afghanistan, allowing it to conduct military attacks against terrorist groups and provide advice and assistance to Afghan forces in key operations.

According to this American publication, retired General Joseph Votel has said that this “whack-a-mole” approach to counterterrorism has ultimately strengthened and made ISIS Khorasan more flexible, with the group now focusing on expanding its influence in other regions.

ISIS-K surging after US left Afghanistan: Former CENTCOM Commander
read more

Mujahid: Kabul’s Stance May Be Cause of Delay in UN Envoy Appointment

Nasir Ahmad Faiq said that consultations regarding the special representative will resume in the coming days.

The Islamic Emirate said that their stance to oppose the appointment of another UN special representative for Afghanistan might be a reason for the delay in the process.

Zabihullah Mujahid, spokesman for the Islamic Emirate, emphasized that there is no need for such a representative for Afghanistan, and said that it is likely that some countries in the United Nations have realized this issue.

“Afghanistan is neither at war nor in crisis to need a UN representative. This was the demand of the Islamic Emirate, some countries in the UN might have realized the issue and this may have led to the delay in appointing an envoy,” Mujahid told TOLOnews.

Meanwhile, Thomas West, the United States special representative for Afghanistan, discussed the full implementation of UN Security Council Resolution 2721 with the deputy permanent representative of the United Arab Emirates to the United Nations.

Nasir Ahmad Faiq, Chargé d’Affaires of Afghanistan’s Permanent Mission to the UN, said that consultations regarding the special representative will resume in the coming days.

“The new envoy will have the responsibility of bringing new changes in Afghanistan to cause change in the country’s political status and to increase engagement between the world and Afghans,” said Wais Nasiri, a political analyst.

“An envoy that works for the betterment of the economic situation of Afghanistan, attracts more humanitarian assistance, resolves internal issues and works for lasting peace and stability, is much needed,” said Salam Paigeer, a political analyst.

Previously, Stéphane Dujarric, the spokesperson for the UN Secretary-General, also stated that the process of selecting the special representative of the United Nations for Afghanistan is ongoing.

Mujahid: Kabul’s Stance May Be Cause of Delay in UN Envoy Appointment
read more

23 Former Government Officials Return Through Contact Commission Last Month

Ahmadullah Wasiq, the spokesperson for this commission, provided details stating that among the returnees was also a Hindu citizen.

The Contact Commission with Personalities of the Islamic Emirate has reported that more than twenty former government members returned to the country over the past month.

Ahmadullah Wasiq, the spokesperson for this commission, provided details stating that among the returnees was also a Hindu citizen.

He assured that efforts to facilitate the return of some former government members are ongoing.

“Through the Contact Commission with Afghan Personalities, 23 individuals have returned to the country, including recently Narendra Singh, who is one of our Sikh compatriots.” said Ahmadullah Wasiq.

However, the question remains: How effective can the return of some political figures and former government members be in addressing the current challenges of the country?

Tariq Farhadi, a political responded, “The reason the Contact Commission has not been successful is that girls’ schools are closed, and if people want to come back with their families, their daughters cannot go to school.”

The spokesperson for the Contact Commission with Personalities emphasized that all individuals returning to the country are safe, and this commission has so far distributed hundreds of immunity cards to the returnees.

23 Former Government Officials Return Through Contact Commission Last Month
read more

Afghanistan Draws 8,200 Foreign Tourists to Historic Sites in Two Years

It is worth mentioning that last year, foreign tourists mostly visited Herat, Balkh, Kandahar, Nuristan, and Ghazni provinces.

The Ministry of Information and Culture of the Islamic Emirate states that over the past two years, more than 8,000 foreign tourists have visited Afghanistan to see the country’s historical sites.

Officials from this ministry emphasize the efforts being made by relevant institutions to provide more facilities to tourists.
The spokesperson for the Ministry of Information and Culture, Khubaib Ghufran, said, ” totally, 8,200 people have come since the victory of the Islamic Emirate. By the end of 1402, (Solar year) we had 8,200 tourists.”

46-year-old Russian Andrei Kazakov who has traveled to over a hundred countries has recently visited Kabul.

He said he had hoped to visit Afghanistan, and now his wish has been fulfilled.

“Afghanistan is very nice. The people are very kind. I realized that I am here just like any other foreigner. They treat me as a friend, offer me hospitality, and ask me questions; so I say that the people here are very good,” He said.

Some economists believe that visits of foreign tourists is beneficial for the country’s economy and also urge the relevant authorities to provide more facilities for foreign tourists in the country.

Economic analyst, Abdul Nasir Rishtia, said: “I think that visiting of tourists in Afghanistan will significantly help increase the country’s revenue.”

It is worth mentioning that last year, foreign tourists mostly visited Herat, Balkh, Kandahar, Nuristan, and Ghazni provinces.

Afghanistan Draws 8,200 Foreign Tourists to Historic Sites in Two Years
read more

Australia Issues Warning Advising Against Travel to Afghanistan

The Australian government once again warned its citizens about traveling to Afghanistan.

The statement by the Australian government said that there is a threat of terrorism and kidnapping in Afghanistan, including in Kabul, and Australians are advised not to travel to this country.

“We’ve reviewed our advice for Afghanistan and continue to advise do not travel due to the extremely dangerous security situation and the very high threat of terrorism and kidnapping, including in Kabul. Terrorists continue to target foreigners, NGOs and humanitarian operations. Foreign nationals, including Australians, also face a serious threat of kidnapping or detention. There are no Australian officials in Afghanistan, and our ability to provide consular and passport assistance to Australians in Afghanistan is severely limited,” the statement reads.

A former member of the Afghan parliament, Shapoor Hassanzoy, commented, saying: “Australia is telling its citizens not to travel to Afghanistan because there is a possibility of danger there, meaning that Westerners have already planned to start a war in Afghanistan and they have complete information about this plan.”

Previously, four other countries, including the United States of America, Germany, Russia, and the United Kingdom, had described travel to Afghanistan as dangerous, a claim that the Islamic Emirate has always rejected.

However, political experts have varying views regarding the travel warnings to Afghanistan.

“If such issues are raised again in Afghanistan, the vulnerable segments of Afghan society will suffer more,” said Samim Shamsi, a political analyst.

“The world should be satisfied at the global level; if satisfaction is not achieved, other countries may create such divisions among nations that they should not travel to Afghanistan,” said Omid Safi  another political analyst

The Islamic Emirate has repeatedly called the concerns of countries about the security of foreign citizens in the country unwarranted and said that the security of foreign citizens in the country is ensured, and other countries should not be concerned about this.

Australia Issues Warning Advising Against Travel to Afghanistan
read more

McCaul: US Pullout Caused Humanitarian Crisis, Aid ‘Flowing to Taliban’

Michael McCaul, the chairman of the United States House Foreign Affairs Committee, once again criticized the Biden adminstration withdrawal for the ongoing humanitarian crisis in Afghanistan, and said aid is supporting the Islamic Emirate.

McCaul stated in a hearing that humanitarian aid is currently not reaching needy women and children in Afghanistan.

The chairman of the US House Foreign Affairs Committee said: “Now I would like to turn to Afghanistan where the Biden administration’s chaotic and deadly withdrawal created a massive humanitarian crisis that we are dealing with today. We know further that taxpayer funding aid is flowing to Taliban fighters and loyalists rather than suffering Afghan women and children.”

The head of the United States International Aid Agency, speaking at the hearing, emphasized that aid organizations have been forced to suspend their activities in some instances to prevent misuse of aid in Afghanistan.

Samantha Power, head of the United States International Aid Agency, said: “We have seen partners that we fund actually suspending assistance because of the diversion, or because women are not being allowed to be employed, depending–there are two reasons to suspend.”

However, the Islamic Emirate has once again denied interference in the distribution of humanitarian aid, stating that they only oversee the distribution process.

Abdul Latif Nazari, a deputy minister at the Ministry of Economy, told TOLOnews: “We reject any interference and appropriation in the process of aid distribution. The Ministry of Economy only supervises to ensure that aid is distributed transparently to deserving and needy individuals.”

Previously, the Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction (SIGAR) reported that the international community had provided nearly $3 billion in aid to Afghanistan since August 2021, of which $2.6 billion was contributed by the United States of America.

McCaul: US Pullout Caused Humanitarian Crisis, Aid ‘Flowing to Taliban’
read more

Officials Say Work on Wakhan Road Rapidly Progressing

Economic experts believe that China is a key country in creating job opportunities in Afghanistan through foundational and developmental projects.

The Acting Minister of Rural Rehabilitation and Development announced during a meeting with the Chinese ambassador in Kabul that the construction of the Wakhan road will soon be completed.

The Acting minister referred to the significance of the Wakhan road in the economic development between China and Afghanistan, stating that the initial work on this road is progressing rapidly and will be completed in the near future.

The spokesperson for the ministry, Noorul Haadi Adil, stated that China has pledged its cooperation with the Islamic Emirate in the implementation of developmental projects and the construction of the Wakhan road.

“The work on the historic route of the Wakhan to the Chinese border is ongoing in a preliminary form by the Ministry of Rural Rehabilitation and Development of the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan, which is currently paused due to Eid. After Eid, the work on this road will resume once again,” he said.

Meanwhile, the Afghanistan Chamber of Commerce and Investment (ACCI) also said that the Wakhan road could play a fundamental role in finding new trade partners for Afghanistan.

The first deputy of the Chamber of Commerce and Investment, Mohammad Younus Momand, told TOLOnews: “Afghanistan is a landlocked country and needs to strengthen its relations with neighbors especially with those neighbors who are of significant economic importance, hence the Wakhan corridor is an important and strategic economic route for the strengthening of economic ties.”

Economic experts believe that China is a key country in creating job opportunities in Afghanistan through foundational and developmental projects.

Economist Sayed Masoud told TOLOnews: “If this is executed and managed seriously, it will have very good results, and moreover, it creates domestic and regional trusts and connects Afghanistan with the entire region.”

Previously, the spokesperson for the Islamic Emirate said that constructing the Wakhan Corridor with China, the start of the Trans-Afghan project, and the extraction of more mines were among the high priorities of the Islamic Emirate for the year 1403.

Officials Say Work on Wakhan Road Rapidly Progressing
read more

Melting glaciers, drying sea highlight Central Asia’s water woes

The site of the former port in Muynak, Karakalpakstan, Uzbekistan, is now an open-air museum — a ship graveyard of forlorn fishing vessels, Sept 12, 2022.
The site of the former port in Muynak, Karakalpakstan, Uzbekistan, is now an open-air museum — a ship graveyard of forlorn fishing vessels,

Climate change and water scarcity are harsh realities facing Central Asia. Glaciers in the east, in the mountains of Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan, are rapidly melting, while in the west, Uzbekistan and Kazakhstan, the Aral Sea has turned into a desert.

According to the World Bank, almost a third of the region’s 80 million people lack access to safe water, highlighting the urgent need to modernize outdated infrastructure. Afghanistan is building a canal that could exacerbate the crisis.

The Syr Darya and Amu Darya rivers provide water for Central Asian countries, but they are drying up.
The Syr Darya and Amu Darya rivers provide water for Central Asian countries, but they are drying up.

Shrinking rivers, drying sea

Last summer and fall in Uzbekistan and Tajikistan, people living along the Syr Darya and Amu Darya rivers described to VOA extreme weather conditions — droughts and floods posing existential dangers.

“It’s all about water, our constant worry,” said Ganikhan Salimov, a cotton farmer in Uzbekistan’s Ferghana region, bordering Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan.

“This water is not just for us, but a source of life for the entire region,” he said, pointing to a muddy canal near his crops.

A board in Muynak, a former port on the Aral Sea, Karakalpakstan, Uzbekistan, Sept. 12, 2022, shows how the sea shrank from 2008 to 2016.
A board in Muynak, a former port on the Aral Sea, Karakalpakstan, Uzbekistan, Sept. 12, 2022, shows how the sea shrank from 2008 to 2016.

The Syr Darya River originates in the Tian Shan Mountains in Kyrgyzstan and Uzbekistan, flowing more than 2,250 kilometers (1,400 miles) west through Tajikistan and Kazakhstan to the northern remnants of the Aral Sea, which has been gradually disappearing for five decades.

The Amu Darya stems from the confluence of the Vakhsh and Panj rivers. Separating Tajikistan and Afghanistan, it runs for 2,400 kilometers (almost 1,500 miles) northwest through Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan into the southern remnants of the Aral.

“We don’t fool ourselves with this magnificent view,” said a local resident who introduced himself only as Bayram, enjoying a hot day with his family on a bank of the Amu Darya in Uzbekistan’s Karakalpakstan Republic, adjacent to Turkmenistan.

“It continuously shrinks and becomes nothing by the time it winds its way to the Aral Sea, which is nowhere to be found,” he said.

A new water deal?

Aggravating the situation, Taliban-run Afghanistan is building a 285-kilometer (177-mile) canal off the Amu Darya, which could draw off 20% to 30% of the water that now goes to Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan.

Tashkent and Ashgabat have been in separate talks with the Taliban, who have argued that the purpose of the canal, called Qosh Tepa, is not to deprive their neighbors of a strategic resource but to provide more water for Afghans.

Central Asian experts express concern over the quality of the Qosh Tepa construction, which started in 2022. Officials in Tashkent say they have offered Kabul technical assistance.

Uzbek President Shavkat Mirziyoyev calls the Taliban “a new stakeholder” not bound by any prior obligations to their northern neighbors. Last September in Tajikistan, at a meeting on the Aral Sea, he proposed a dialogue of riparian countries.

“We believe it is necessary to set up a joint working group to study all aspects of the construction of the Qosh Tepa canal and its impact on the water regime of the Amu Darya involving our research institutes,” Mirziyoyev said.

Children enjoy a hot day in Kegeyli, Karakalpakstan, which depends on the Amu Darya River as a water source, July 22, 2023.
Children enjoy a hot day in Kegeyli, Karakalpakstan, which depends on the Amu Darya River as a water source, July 22, 2023.

No progress has been made since then, but Eric Rudenshiold, a former U.S. official with decades of experience working with Central Asian governments, believes the best outcome would be a new water-sharing agreement.

“Afghanistan, Uzbekistan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, all are facing water shortage issues, and so cooperation is really the only answer. And the question is, at what point these countries do that. Cooperation is much better than conflict,” he told VOA.

They would not even talk to each other on these issues until recently, Rudenshiold said.

“We’ve seen Central Asian states lean forward to engage with the Taliban, and I think that’s a big step,” he said.

While optimistic about the prospects for regional dialogue, Rudenshiold said he doubts Western governments will participate, given their strong opposition to the Taliban and its repressive policies.

“I think the region is going to have to resolve this issue itself, not relying on international organizations or other powers, but actually having the countries come together,” Rudenshiold said.

He sees enough leverage to negotiate: Uzbekistan, Tajikistan and Turkmenistan provide power to Afghanistan. “The question is, how do you add water into that equation?”

“Yes, Afghanistan can take water for agriculture and drinking water. The problem is it’s still depleting, and Afghanistan needs to be part of the solution,” Rudenshiold said.

America’s offering

At a recent forum at the Wilson Center in Washington, U.S. officials and Central Asian diplomats highlighted growing water demand and worsening environmental conditions.

Tajikistan’s ambassador, Farrukh Hamralizoda, said that “more than 1,000 of the 30,000 glaciers” in his country have already melted.

“Every year, we suffer from floods, landslides, avalanches and other water-related natural disasters,” Hamralizoda said, adding that his mountainous country generates 98% of its electricity from hydropower.

This is what's left of Syr Darya River in a good year, say residents of Khujand, Tajikistan, pointing to a river steadily shrinking, Sept 4, 2023.
This is what’s left of Syr Darya River in a good year, say residents of Khujand, Tajikistan, pointing to a river steadily shrinking, Sept 4, 2023.

Kyrgyzstan’s ambassador, Baktybek Amanbaev, said glaciers have also been vanishing in his similarly mountainous country, which he said hosts 30% of the clean water in the five former Soviet republics that make up Central Asia.

“We need effective water management to be able to estimate water reserves and flows,” Amanbaev said.

To that end, the U.S. Agency for International Development is funding MODSNOW, a digital program for hydrological forecasting that uses satellite imaging to monitor snow depth and melt and water flows from the mountains.

By providing governments and local stakeholders with accurate and timely data, the U.S. hopes to enable informed decision-making and sustainable management of resources.

“With accelerated snowmelt and heavy rainfall events also comes the greater risk of landslides and other severe natural disasters,” said Anjali Kaur, the agency’s deputy administrator, also speaking at the Wilson Center.

Melting glaciers, drying sea highlight Central Asia’s water woes
read more