Malala: I never imagined women’s rights would be lost so easily

Amber Sandhu & Kulsum Hafeji

BBC Newsbeat
Getty Images Malala Yousafzai, posing for the camera while wearing traditional clothing in a pale pink colour with matching headscarf.
Malala Yousafzai has campaigned for women’s rights since she was shot by a Taliban gunman in 2012

A bullet failed to silence her, now Malala Yousafzai is lending her voice to the women of Afghanistan.

In just a few years since the Taliban retook control of the country, women’s rights have been eroded to the point where even singing is banned.

Malala has a personal history with the Taliban across the border in Pakistan, after a gunman from the hardline Islamist group shot her as she sat on a school bus.

The speed of change in Afghanistan, if not the brutality, has surprised Malala, who since that near-fatal shooting in 2012 has campaigned for equality.

“I never imagined that the rights of women would be compromised so easily,” Malala tells BBC Asian Network.

“A lot of girls are finding themselves in a very hopeless, depressing situation where they do not see any way out,” the 27-year-old Nobel Prize Winner says.

“The future looks very dark to them.”

In 2021, the Taliban regained power in Afghanistan, 20 years after a US-led invasion toppled their regime in the fallout of the 9/11 attacks in New York.

In the three-and-a-half years since Western forces left the country, “morality laws” have meant women in Afghanistan have lost dozens of rights.

A dress code means they must be fully covered and strict rules have banned them from travelling without a male chaperone or looking a man in the eye unless they’re related by blood or marriage.

“The restrictions are just so extreme that it does not even make sense to anybody,” says Malala.

The United Nations (UN) says the rules amount to “gender apartheid” – a system where people face economic and social discrimination based on their sex and something human rights group Amnesty International wants recognised as crime under international law.

But the rules have been defended by the Taliban, which claims they’re accepted in Afghan society and that the international community should respect “Islamic laws, traditions and the values of Muslim societies”.

Apple TV+ A still from Bread & Roses where an Afghan woman holds her right hand to her face, on which she's written #StandWithWomenInAfghanistan. She wears a silver ring on her right ring finger and covers her hair with a patterned scarf. Apple TV+
Malala’s worked on a new film that follows the lives of three Afghan women as their rights are stripped away

“Women lost everything,” says Malala.

“They [the Taliban] know that to take away women’s rights you have to start with the foundation, and that is education.”

The UN says since the takeover more than a million girls are not in school in Afghanistan – about 80% – and in 2022 about 100,000 female students were banned from their university courses.

It’s also reported a correlation between the lack of access to education and a rise in child marriage and deaths during pregnancy and childbirth.

“Afghan women live in very dark times now,” Malala says.

“But they show resistance.”

The Pakistan-born activist, who became the youngest person ever to win a Nobel Peace Prize, is an executive producer on an upcoming film, Bread & Roses, that documents the lives of three Afghan women living under the Taliban regime.

The documentary follows Zahra, a dentist forced to give up her practice, activist Taranom, who flees to the border, and government employee Sharifa, who loses her job and her independence.

But the film isn’t just about the stories of three women, Malala says.

“It’s about the 20 million Afghan girls and women whose stories may not make it to our screens.”

Bread & Roses was directed by Afghan filmmaker Sahra Mani and US actress Jennifer Lawrence was also brought on board as a producer.

Apple TV+ A still from Bread & Roses showing three women sitting together on the floor. The woman in the middle writes on the hand of the woman sitting to her left while the third woman looks at sheets of paper spread on the carpet. Apple TV+
The Taliban were ousted when US-led troops invaded Afghanistan in 2001 but returned to power 20 years later

Sahra tells Asian Network her mission was “to tell the story of a nation under the Taliban dictatorship”.

“How slowly, all the rights have been taken away.”

Sahra managed to flee Afghanistan after the US-backed government collapsed following the withdrawal of troops in August 2021.

But she kept in touch with women back home, who would share videos which she then collected and archived.

“It was very important to find young, modern, educated women that have talent they were ready to dedicate to society,” says Sahra.

“They were ready to build the country but now they have to sit at home and almost do nothing.”

Retired US generals describe chaos of Afghan exit.

Afghan withdrawal was a dark chapter for UK – MP

Even though the film hasn’t been released yet, Sahra believes the situation in Afghanistan has already deteriorated to the point where it would be impossible to make if she started now.

“At that time, women could still go out and demonstrate,” she says.

“Nowadays, women are not even allowed to sing… the situation is getting more difficult.”

The first-hand footage shows the women at protests – they kept the cameras rolling while being arrested by the Taliban.

And Sahra says the project only got harder over time as more of their rights were stripped away.

“We were really honoured that these women trusted us to share their stories,” she says.

“And it was really important for us to put their security in our priorities.

“But when they were out in the street asking for their rights, it was not for the documentary.

“It was for them, for their own life, for their own freedom.”

Apple TV+ A still from Bread & Roses of a women's march. A long line of women walk along a path in Kabul holding placards while a woman dressed in a black dress and headscarf in the right-hand corner of the image takes a selfie. The city seems wintry, with no leaves on the trees and many of the protesters dressed in warm coats. Apple TV+
US actress Jennifer Lawrence produced the film which she says is about “the nature of resistance”

Malala says that, for women in Afghanistan, “defiance is extremely challenging”.

“Despite all of these challenges, they’re out on their streets and risking their lives to hope for a better world for themselves.”

All three of the women featured in the film are no longer living in Afghanistan and Sahra and Malala are hopeful the film will raise awareness of what women who remain endure.

“They are doing all that they can to fight for their rights, to raise their voices,” Malala says.

“They’re putting so much at risk. It’s our time to be their sisters and be their supporters.”

Malala also hopes the documentary prompts more international pressure on the Taliban to restore women’s rights.

“I was completely shocked when I saw the reality of the Taliban take over,” she says.

“We really have to question what sort of systems we have put in place to guarantee protection to women in Afghanistan, but also elsewhere.”

And as much as Bread & Roses deals with stories of loss and oppression, the film is also about resilience and hope.

“There’s so much for us to learn from the bravery and courage of these Afghan women,” says Malala.

“If they are not scared, if they are not losing that courage to stand up to the Taliban, we should learn from them and we should stand in solidarity with them.”

The title itself was inspired by an Afghan saying.

“Bread is a symbol of freedom, earning a salary and supporting the family,” Sahra says.

“We have a saying in my language that the one who gave you bread is the one who orders you.

“So if you find your bread, that means you are the boss of you.”

That’s exactly the future she hopes to see for the women of Afghanistan and, based on what she’s seen, one she believes they will achieve in the end.

“Women in Afghanistan, they keep changing the tactic,” she says.

“They keep searching for a new way to keep fighting back.”

Listen to an extended interview with Malala and Sahra on BBC Asian Network News Presents at 23:00 on 18 November or catch up on BBC Sounds.

Bread & Roses will be streamed globally on Apple TV+ from 22 November.

Additional reporting by Riyah Collins.

Malala: I never imagined women’s rights would be lost so easily
read more

Revealed: the truth behind the Taliban’s brutal Kabul ‘regeneration’ programme

By , Jessica Purkiss and Fahim Abed

The Guardian

When the Taliban began a sweeping redevelopment drive in Kabul soon after returning to power three years ago, they claimed there was a need to modernise Afghanistan’s historic capital. A new investigation, however, reveals that the Taliban’s regeneration programme has left thousands of people homeless and had a brutal impact on the most vulnerable communities, with claims of properties being demolished with children still inside.

Using satellite imagery, social media footage and testimony from Afghan residents, the findings offer a first comprehensive insight into the Taliban’s ambitious redevelopment of Kabul – but also its true cost.

Satellite analysis indicates that 1.56 sq km (385 acres) of the city – the equivalent of more than 220 football pitches – was flattened within the city between August 2021 and August 2024.

The investigation, a collaboration between the Guardian, the Centre for Information Resilience’s Afghan Witness project, Lighthouse Reports and the Afghan news outlets Zan Times and Etilaat Roz also uncovered signs that the destruction is in part linked to ethnicity.

The satellite analysis, carried out by Afghan Witness, showed that of the six most-affected districts – where at least 50,000 sq metres (12 acres) of residential properties were demolished – three were areas populated by the minority Hazara community and two were populated by the minority Tajiks.

Most affected was Kabul’s District 13, a predominantly Hazara area.

The investigation also analysed the large-scale razing of “informal settlements”. In some cases, the destruction of the sprawling slums, which are typically inhabited by poorer communities displaced by conflict or climate change – have been conducted so brutally that residents reported injuries and deaths.

In at least two settlements, residents allege that homes were demolished with people still inside. In one large slum – in Kabul’s District 22 – evicted families alleged that a four-year-old and a 15-year-old died during its demolition.

“Women, children and elderly men were begging for them to stop the destruction until we can find a shelter, but they wouldn’t listen,” said a resident, who had spent a decade in the settlement after being displaced from Pakistan.

He claimed in the aftermath of the demolition his young niece also died from lack of shelter after their home was destroyed during the heat of summer.

Residents who attempted to film such demolitions were reportedly beaten.

In another significant destruction of an informal settlement in the north of the city, the Taliban’s administration in Kabul tweeted a series of photos in August 2024 chronicling bulldozers razing structures.

Residents described scenes of mayhem and desperation as the site was demolished. “It was like the earthquake in Herat [which killed thousands last year]. Houses were buried; all our belongings were also buried,” said one resident.

A small child standing beside a small shelter open on three sides with a tarpaulin held up by poles
The crude shelter one resident’s family in District 4 has been living in since the demolitions.

Others testified that homes were demolished with people inside. “My nephew came by, crying that his mother and brother were inside the house and the loader was demolishing it,” said one.

Jalaluddin, who lived in the settlement with nearly 50 family members for two decades, said he could not afford to rent a new home and was now living in an abandoned factory.

“We don’t even have tents – we just have shelters made from plastic pieces. Some days we don’t have anything to eat. We sleep with an empty stomach,” he said.

Many of the land-clearance projects in residential areas are for building or widening roads.

Fakhrullah Sarwari, an urban planner who worked with the former Afghan government, said: “Most of these plans were part of previous government plans, but they were unable to be implemented because they couldn’t force people to evacuate the area.

“We do need better mobility, but with the majority of the population living below the poverty line, demolishing homes to build wider roads doesn’t address underlying issues,” he said.

Human rights groups say women are particularly vulnerable after eviction, warning it can increase gender-based violence.

One woman, interviewed by Zan Times, reveals the difficulties of female-led households. Offering cleaning services door to door, she earns between one and three dollars a day and has struggled to get compensation from the Taliban after they demolished her home in a residential area in north Kabul.

One reason is that she is not allowed into Kabul’s municipal offices without a male guardian to accompany her, under the Taliban’s rules of segregation.

A settlement that has been partially demolished. many building have been reduced to low walls.
Residents say fear has prevented them protesting over the loss of their homes. Photograph: X/Municipality status

Another woman who lost her home in the same area can no longer work due to Taliban restrictions. Denied compensation, her family must rely solely on her husband’s modest income repairing shoes.

Of a dozen people evicted who were interviewed for the investigation, only one had found permanent accommodation since their eviction. Residents say fear prevents them from protesting at the destruction of their homes.

The demolitions come months after the UN warned that Afghanistan’s economy had “basically collapsed” with rampant food insecurity and 6.3 million people displaced within the country.

One woman, whose family home of 40 years was demolished in August 2023, said: “At first, they told us that they would compensate us and not leave us homeless, but once the houses were demolished, nobody cared about us.”

Her family stopped travelling to the municipal offices to ask for their compensation when they could no longer afford the bus fare.

The Taliban authorities have not commented on the findings. They have previously justified the demolition of informal settlements as reclaiming stolen land acquired by “opportunists and usurpers”. They also state that residential land is often cleared for infrastructure projects.

* Additional reporting by Sabrina SlipchenkoElyas Nawandish and Kreshma Fakhri

Revealed: the truth behind the Taliban’s brutal Kabul ‘regeneration’ programme
read more

Pakistan provides China with fresh information on TTP activities in Afghanistan

Pakistani media reported that Islamabad shared “compelling evidence” with China’s Special Representative for Afghanistan, Yu Xiaoyong, regarding the presence of Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) and other groups operating from Afghan territory.

According to The Express Tribune, Pakistan’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs presented this evidence during Yu Xiaoyong’s visit to Islamabad on Monday, November 18.

The report noted that the Chinese envoy’s trip to Islamabad came just days after Russian Special Envoy Zamir Kabulov’s visit, highlighting the growing international focus on Afghanistan’s role in regional security.

Citing sources, The Express Tribune stated that Pakistan briefed the Chinese envoy about the current situation in Afghanistan, detailing how terrorist groups such as the TTP have been using Afghanistan’s territory.

Pakistani officials reportedly shared compelling evidence about terrorist sanctuaries in Afghanistan and emphasized that it is time for a collective stance against the Taliban regime to ensure they fulfill their commitments to the international community.

The Afghan Taliban, however, have consistently denied Pakistan’s allegations, asserting that no terrorist groups are allowed to use Afghanistan’s soil against any country.

The conflicting narratives highlight the ongoing challenges in addressing regional security concerns and fostering trust among stakeholders.

These discussions underscore the growing frustration in Islamabad over what it perceives as the Taliban regime’s failure to act against militant groups that threaten regional stability.

Pakistan’s calls for a united international response indicate its desire to increase pressure on the Taliban government.

The involvement of China and Russia in these talks signals the international community’s recognition of the deteriorating security situation in Afghanistan and its broader implications.

A coordinated regional approach may be critical to addressing the escalating threats posed by militant groups.

Pakistan provides China with fresh information on TTP activities in Afghanistan
read more

China, Pakistan Discuss Collaborating to Foster Peace in Afghanistan

Prior to Yue Xiaoyong’s visit, Zamir Kabulov, Russia’s Special Representative for Afghanistan, also visited Pakistan and held talks on Afghanistan.

Yue Xiaoyong, China’s Special Representative for Afghanistan, met with senior Pakistani officials to discuss relations with Afghanistan and the role of neighboring countries in fostering peace and stability. The discussions were held with Amina Baloch, Foreign Secretary, and Ahmad Naseem Warraich, Additional Foreign Secretary (Afghanistan and West Asia) at Pakistan’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs.

According to a statement from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the talks focused on strengthening relations with Afghanistan and emphasized the critical role of neighboring countries in ensuring stability. The statement said, “The Chinese Special Envoy on Afghan Affairs, Ambassador Yue Xiaoyong, called on Foreign Secretary Ms. Amina Baloch today. He also held detailed consultations with the Additional Foreign Secretary (Afghanistan and West Asia), Ambassador Ahmad Naseem Warraich. Both sides exchanged views on relations with Afghanistan and reaffirmed the vital role of neighboring countries for a peaceful and stable Afghanistan.”

Prior to Yue Xiaoyong’s visit, Zamir Kabulov, Russia’s Special Representative for Afghanistan, also visited Pakistan and held talks on Afghanistan. China and Russia, key allies of Afghanistan’s interim government, have consistently expressed their support for peace and regional stability.

Ahead of his visit to Pakistan, Yue Xiaoyong told a Chinese media outlet that regional and neighboring countries had agreed to collaborate in achieving peace and stability in Afghanistan.

Political analyst Salim Paigir told TOLOnews, “Russia, China, India, and Iran are major regional powers that can play a significant role, provided that Pakistan acts sincerely in its dealings with Afghanistan and the region.”

Another analyst, Moeen Gul Samkani, stated: “China and Russia are seeking to create a military, political, and economic bloc, but the West and the United States are unlikely to allow this. The West aims to maintain control over Afghanistan and India to counter Russia, Iran, Central Asia, and China.”

Both China and Russia continue to stress the importance of neighboring countries in fostering peace and stability in Afghanistan. During his visit to Pakistan, Zamir Kabulov also underscored the critical role of Afghanistan’s neighbors in resolving the country’s challenges.

China, Pakistan Discuss Collaborating to Foster Peace in Afghanistan
read more

33% of Afghans Without Healthcare, WHO Official Warns

Salvador pointed out that decades of continuous challenges have left Afghanistan’s healthcare system fragile, requiring a structural approach to address its issues.

Edwin Ceniza Salvador, the World Health Organization’s (WHO) Representative in Afghanistan, revealed in an exclusive interview with TOLOnews that 33% of Afghanistan’s population still lacks access to healthcare services.

He further explained that budget constraints have forced the closure of 226 healthcare centers previously supported by the WHO in Afghanistan.

Speaking about the healthcare gap, Salvador stated: “About 67% of the population currently has access, which means that about 33% of the population do not have access to the health services. And these are, like I mentioned, most people in the rural areas and most that are geographically difficult to access in winter seasons.”

Salvador pointed out that decades of continuous challenges have left Afghanistan’s healthcare system fragile, requiring a structural approach to address its issues. Reflecting on the impact of the 2021 political transition, he noted that many Afghan doctors have since left the country.

“There was a change in 2021. We’ll have to, number one, build again the capacity of the people who are remaining in the country. Number two, to see if some of the people who are abroad will be able to come back, so that they will be able to at least help the people back in their country,” Salvador said.

The WHO representative emphasized ongoing efforts to train midwives and underscored the need to support healthcare workers, particularly female doctors and nurses, across Afghanistan.

“The authorities, when I meet them, like when I visit the local authorities in the different provinces I’ve been, I basically said that now with the change that has been in place, we will come a time where we will run out of female midwives because the educational system has been impacted, you know, at the current state. The same for doctors. I basically also proposed and gave a scenario where I said, would you be comfortable where it is a male doctor treating your mother, your wife, your sister, your daughters, your aunties, and relatives,” Salvador warned.

In remote areas of Afghanistan, healthcare services remain inadequate, with many citizens unable to access even basic medical care. Nevertheless, the Ministry of Public Health has assured that efforts are underway to increase the number of healthcare centers throughout the country.

33% of Afghans Without Healthcare, WHO Official Warns
read more

Attack From Afghanistan Kills Chinese National In Tajikistan, Sources Say

Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty

Tajik troops in the volatile Shamsiddin Shohin district bordering Afghanistan (file photo)

Tajik troops in the volatile Shamsiddin Shohin district bordering Afghanistan (file photo)

One Chinese national was killed and five others, four of them Chinese, were injured in a cross-border attack in Tajikistan’s Zarbuzi Gorge, two sources close to a Tajik investigation told RFE/RL’s Tajik Service on November 18.

The incident, which occurred in the southeastern Shamsiddin Shohin district, bordering Afghanistan, has not yet been officially addressed by the Tajik authorities.

According to the sources, the attack was carried out by armed individuals who crossed the border from Afghanistan. It remains unclear whether the attackers were criminals possibly involved in drug trafficking, a crime that is common in the area, or members of a militant group.

“Among the five injured, four are Chinese nationals and one is a local resident. All have been hospitalized in Shamsiddin Shohin district,” one of the sources said.

The Chinese nationals were reportedly working at a gold mine in the Zarbuzi Gorge. The attack marks the first known incident resulting in the death of a Chinese national in the volatile region.

The Shamsiddin Shohin district shares a porous border with Afghanistan that is often crossed by smugglers and militant groups.

Although the Taliban has assured neighboring countries that Afghan territory will not serve as a base for terrorist activities, Tajik authorities have been on high alert in recent years.

The deadly attack underscores persistent security concerns along Tajikistan’s southern frontier.

In August 2023, Tajikistan’s State Committee for National Security reported killing three members of the banned Ansarullah militant group and seizing weapons in a separate cross-border operation.

These incidents highlight the ongoing threats posed by instability in Afghanistan, despite regional efforts to secure the border.

 

Attack From Afghanistan Kills Chinese National In Tajikistan, Sources Say
read more

Qatar, Turkey Advocate for Inclusive Govt and Stability in Afghanistan

Previously, the presidents of Türkiye and Uzbekistan have pledged support for Afghanistan during the 11th Summit of the Turkic States in Bishkek.

The President of Türkiye and the Emir of Qatar, in a joint statement, emphasized the formation of an inclusive government and the importance of respecting citizens’ rights in Afghanistan.

In this joint statement, released at the conclusion of the 10th High-Level Strategic Committee meeting between the two countries, both parties reiterated their commitment to strengthening Afghanistan’s stability and engaging with the country in coordination with the independent assessment of the UN Secretary-General’s Special Coordinator.

The Joint Communique of the 10th Session of the Supreme Strategic Committee Between Qatar, Türkiye reads: “Qatar and Turkiye reaffirmed their commitment to promoting stability in Afghanistan. They emphasized the importance of respecting fundamental rights and inclusive governance and also highlighted the need for coordinated engagement with Afghanistan.”

Although the Islamic Emirate has not commented on demands related to the formation of an inclusive government, it has praised the stance of the two countries on ensuring peace and stability in Afghanistan.

Hamdullah Fitrat, Deputy Spokesperson of the Islamic Emirate, stated: “We commend the stance of Qatar and Türkiye for emphasizing peace and stability in Afghanistan. Afghanistan’s stability benefits all countries. The Islamic Emirate ensures the Sharia-based rights of all Afghan citizens and, as a responsible government, strives for the security, economy, and well-being of its citizens.”

Sayed Akbar Sial Wardak, a political analyst, commented on the nature of an inclusive government, saying: “The definition and type of an inclusive government are not clear, and it is up to the Afghans to determine it. The current Afghan government should focus on this and discuss it to establish a system that satisfies all Afghan people.”

Previously, the presidents of Türkiye and Uzbekistan have pledged support for Afghanistan during the 11th Summit of the Turkic States in Bishkek.

Qatar, Turkey Advocate for Inclusive Govt and Stability in Afghanistan
read more

Pakistan warns Taliban: Don’t test our patience

Khaama Press

The spokesperson for Pakistan’s Foreign Ministry urged the Taliban on Thursday to take immediate and effective action against Pakistani militants based in Afghanistan, deeming any support for them unacceptable.

Mumtaz Zahra Baloch warned the Afghan Taliban not to “test the patience of the Pakistani people.”

In a weekly press briefing reported by The Express Tribune, Mumtaz Zahra Baloch stated, “Afghanistan must not allow its territory to be used for terrorism against Pakistan or any neighboring country.”

She emphasized that besides Pakistan, Afghanistan’s other neighboring countries have also called on the Taliban to take action against terrorist groups using Afghanistan as a safe haven.

The spokesperson reiterated Pakistan’s demand that Afghanistan soil must not be used against Pakistan and other neighboring nations.

She warned the Taliban to take Pakistan’s repeated concerns regarding militants seriously and to “stop testing the patience of the Pakistani people.”

The escalating insecurity caused by deadly attacks from militant groups, particularly the Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP), has fueled Islamabad’s frustration and anger toward the Afghan Taliban.

The growing insecurity in Pakistan due to militant activity, along with the Afghan Taliban’s perceived inaction, has heightened tensions between the two nations. Islamabad’s demands for accountability and action may lead to strained diplomatic ties, further complicating the regional security dynamics.

Meanwhile, India has been quietly increasing its engagement with the Taliban, focusing on economic projects and humanitarian aid. This growing relationship could shift the balance of influence in the region, as India positions itself as a key player in Afghanistan’s reconstruction and a counterweight to Pakistan’s dominance in the country affairs.

Pakistan warns Taliban: Don’t test our patience
read more

German Chancellor summoned to address Afghanistan evacuation operation

German Chancellor Olaf Scholz was summoned to a parliamentary inquiry committee on Thursday to address questions about the military evacuation from Afghanistan in 2021.

The committee is investigating the withdrawal of German forces and the country’s response to the Taliban’s takeover of  Kabul.

As a witness, Chancellor Scholz is expected to answer questions posed by parliamentarians during the session.

According to Germany’s Deutschlandfunk news agency, the inquiry aims to scrutinize the circumstances surrounding the Kabul evacuation operation in August 2021.

The operation remains under examination due to the rapid collapse of Afghanistan and the Taliban’s rise to power.

At the time of the evacuation, Scholz served as the Deputy Chancellor and Finance Minister in Angela Merkel’s cabinet.

In addition to Scholz, former Defense Minister Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer has also been invited to the parliamentary session.

German media reports indicate that in December, former Chancellor Angela Merkel and former Foreign Minister Heiko Maas are also scheduled to testify as witnesses before the inquiry committee.

Reports suggest that due to Germany’s upcoming early parliamentary elections, the preparation of the final report might be expedited to meet time constraints.

Amid rising tensions, European countries, including Germany, have intensified the deportation of Afghan refugees, especially those with criminal records.

This reflects a broader shift in Europe’s immigration policies, where security concerns and public sentiment are driving stricter measures against asylum seekers.

The increased deportations are exacerbating the plight of Afghan refugees, many of whom face dire conditions upon return. Human rights organizations have raised concerns about the safety of deported individuals, particularly those at risk of persecution in Afghanistan under Taliban rule.

This trend underscores the challenges facing both host nations and refugees in navigating the complexities of global displacement.

German Chancellor summoned to address Afghanistan evacuation operation
read more

Foreign Policy Piece Calls for US, West to Engage With Afghanistan

It also reads that the Islamic Emirate leadership prefers de facto engagement and displays of diplomatic respect to de jure legitimacy. 

A Foreign Policy opinion piece by Jens Vesterlund Mathiesen, Adam Weinstein, and Galina Mikkelsen says that the new US administration led by President-elect Donald Trump and the West will face renewed opportunities and challenges in their approach to Afghanistan.

Referring to the discontinuation of the position of the US special representative for Afghanistan in October, and the closing of Afghan embassies in Europe, the piece says that Donald Trump will inherit nearly “deadlocked US relations” with the Islamic Emirate.

The piece called for coordinated US-European diplomacy on Afghanistan and suggested that the West should accept the current reality of Afghanistan rather than hoping to fracture the ‘Taliban’ from within.

It also reads that the Islamic Emirate leadership prefers de facto engagement and displays of diplomatic respect to de jure legitimacy.

“There’s no shortage of engagement with the Taliban by non-Western powers. Aaron Zelin of the Washington Institute has meticulously tracked all Taliban diplomatic meetings since August 2021, nearly 2,000 in their first three years in power, with meetings accelerating year on year,” the article reads.

The writers criticized the Western strategy of non-recognition and questioned the US’s and Europe’s distancing from Afghanistan while regional countries benefit from their engagement with the country.

The piece said that regional countries have achieved much from their engagement with Kabul.

The abandonment of Afghanistan by the West would be a mistake, the writers said, who encouraged face-to-face interaction with the current Afghan authorities rather than engaging from a distance.

“The United States and Europe could move beyond occasional engagement in Doha and sporadic meetings in Kabul to take a long-term approach by meeting with the Taliban and the Afghan people inside Afghanistan. By following the example of regional states in demonstrating respect through dialogue, Western diplomats can leverage the power of face-to-face interactions, recognizing that effective diplomacy is rooted in building personal relationships,” the article said.

Although the Islamic Emirate has repeatedly said that Daesh has been defeated in Afghanistan, the writers in the Foreign Policy piece wrote that the Islamic Emirate can be a counterterrorism partner of the West against their “shared” threat, ISKP.

The piece said that Donald Trump, as the architect of the Doha agreement, should pursue a forward-looking diplomacy, rather than return to the mistakes of the past.

This comes as the former US special envoy for Afghan peace, Zalmay Khalilzad, on X wrote that the reelection of Donald Trump is an opening for full implementation of the Doha agreement, and as Kabul is urging the president-elect to open a new chapter in US-Afghan relations.

Foreign Policy Piece Calls for US, West to Engage With Afghanistan
read more