Taliban causing ‘irreversible damage’ to whole education system in Afghanistan

The Taliban is causing “irreversible damage” to Afghanistan’s education system through the reintroduction of corporal punishment, curriculum changes and the use of unqualified teachers to replace women, most of whom have been barred from schools, Human Rights Watch has warned.

After taking power in 2021, the Taliban banned girls from secondary schools. A new report from Human Rights Watch (HRW), published on Wednesday, warns that boys’ education has also suffered under the Taliban, although this has gone largely unreported.

HRW said the ban on female teachers had left a gap that had been filled by unqualified men and had reduced the range of subjects being taught.

Sahar Fetrat, assistant women’s rights researcher at HRW, said: “The Taliban are causing irreversible damage to the Afghan education system for boys as well as girls. By harming the whole school system in the country, they risk creating a lost generation deprived of a quality education.”

A group of school girls raise their hands with school books on their laps
Taliban could be convinced to open girls’ schools, says Afghanistan ex-education minister

The report said subjects such as the arts, sports and civics had been removed from the curriculum in many schools.

A document obtained by HRW, which it could not verify, proposed some of the changes that had occurred in schools. The document described the previous Afghan curriculum as using “un-Islamic and non-Afghan standards that resemble western standards”.

It complained that the curriculum encouraged western values and dress, promoted democracy, covered other faiths and taught pupils about non-Muslim writers, including Shakespeare.

HRW said there had been an increase in corporal punishment in schools since the Taliban took power. Boys are beaten and slapped, and have their feet whipped for having a mobile phone or not complying with new rigid rules on haircuts or clothing, which must be traditionally Afghan.

Zaman A, a pupil from Herat province quoted in the HRW report, said: “The Taliban’s strict rules are suffocating. Currently, as a student, wearing anything colourful is treated like a sin.

“Wearing shirts or T-shirts, ties or suits are all treated like crimes,” he said. “Every day, there are several cases where boys get punished during morning assembly or in classrooms for some of these reasons.”

HRW also said boys were coming under increasing pressure to work instead of going to school as Afghanistan grapples with drought, conflict and a crippling economic crisis. More than 28 million Afghans are in need of urgent assistance, with 6 million people at emergency levels of food insecurity – one step away from famine.

The rights group said boys were struggling with anxiety and depression because of the pressure to support their families.

While progress was made in education under the previous Afghan government, the Taliban swiftly banned girls from school after taking power in 2021. Last year it banned women from higher education, including from medical degrees, which will affect the future number of female healthcare workers.

Last week a report by ACAPS, a non-profit organisation that supports aid workers with analysis of humanitarian situations, reported that the Taliban’s promises to ease curbs on women and lift restrictions on access to education had been merely symbolic, used in negotiations with international partners but in effect unimplemented.

Fetrat said: “The Taliban’s impact on the education system is harming children today and will haunt Afghanistan’s future. An immediate and effective international response is desperately needed to address Afghanistan’s education crisis.”

Taliban causing ‘irreversible damage’ to whole education system in Afghanistan
read more

Inside the remote army base where hero Afghans are housed after being welcomed to the UK

Holly Bancroft

Social Affairs Correspondent

The Independent (UK)
1 Dec 2023
The Ministry of Defence has transferred more than 1,100 Afghans to Garats Hay under a secretive mission codenamed Operation Lazurite
Inside Operation Lazurite: Look inside the army base being used to welcome Afghans to the UK

Arriving in the darkness, the packed coach passes through the imposing metal fence and pulls up on a remote and silent army base. Shuffled off the coach one by one, the group of men, women and children are taken to a large hall, before being handed, among other items, a tube of toothpaste.

One woman is 38 weeks pregnant, desperate for a safe place to bring her child into the world. Others have been waiting more than a year to find sanctuary.

Finally, they are in the UK.

“Now we feel like we are home,” one Afghan father, who spent a year in a hotel in Pakistan waiting for relocation to the UK, told The Independent. “We are feeling better and out of pressure. We have been waiting for this moment, thinking of the day when we would arrive in the UK, and fortunately we are here now.”

This man is one of more than 1,000 Afghans staying temporarily at MoD Garats Hay in Leicestershire because of their years of service alongside the British armed forces in the war against the Taliban.

All, like him, have been eligible to come to the UK for months – sometimes years – but have only been brought to Britain in recent weeks as part of a secretive Ministry of Defence operation, codenamed Operation Lazurite.

On 28 September, word went out to B Company, 3rd Battalion Parachute Regiment, that they had 72 hours to mobilise Garats Hay – a base in the countryside 12 minutes drive from Loughborough – to welcome hundreds of Afghan families.

MoD Garats Hay is based on the old Beaumanor estate, which was requisitioned by the War Office in 1939 and used as a radio intercept station. After the war, it was used by the Royal Signals until 1998.

In the 2000s, the remote army base, which is surrounded by a high metal fence, was used as a sixth-form college to train students who wanted to join the army before it was then turned into a Covid isolation facility during the pandemic. Most recently, it had been used as a training and conference centre.

As Garats Hay had been in recent use, it is in a very different condition compared to military sites that have been offered to the Home Office to house asylum seekers.

The site is being used, along with Swynnerton camp in Staffordshire, to temporarily house families before they are moved into service accommodation homes. Some are first moved into flats on other barracks for six weeks while they are matched with a more permanent property.

When The Independent visited Garats Hay last week, there were 175 Afghans on site, comprising 40 families. Some 1,100 people have been processed through the base and there are 61 service men and women on site in a 24-hour operation.

Meanwhile, there were around 100 Afghans based at Swynnerton, an old Second World War training camp. In total, 126 service personnel have been deployed at seven locations across the country.

Afghans arriving from Pakistan are met off the plane by officials who get them on to coaches to Garats Hay, usually in the early hours of the morning. They disembark from the coaches in groups before being taken to the lecture hall for processing, where they are given a translated briefing pack and a box full of essentials such as toothpaste, baby food and snacks.

Those who are being moved on within a few hours to more permanent homes are put in a room that has been turned into a transit lounge, which has been fitted with pool and air hockey tables and mattresses.

Those who are staying at Garats Hay for a bit longer are sorted out with rooms in the five former student accommodation blocks. The MoD aims – but doesn’t always succeed – to get people through the site within two days. The longest one family had been at the base for was three weeks and two days when The Independent visited.

On-site is an old library which has been cleared out to make a prayer area, as well as an adjoining room transformed into a makeshift multi-faith space.Families have their food provided at the former school canteen

Families get canteen food provided during their stay, with a children’s menu for youngsters. A tuck shop is opened three times a week, providing raisins, digestive biscuits, Colgate toothpaste, infant milk, baby shampoo and other essentials.

Around 20 interpreters have been brought onto the site to live alongside the Afghan families to make sure they can communicate any issues to the army personnel. An army medic has also set up a GP clinic on-site three times a week for anyone who gets ill.

The medical team have already seen one case of malaria, a number of people with dengue fever and others with scabies, with protocols in place to try to halt any spread of infection.

The most challenging case so far was when one woman arrived at 38 weeks pregnant, having downplayed how far along she was out of desperation to finally leave the hotels in Pakistan.

The Afghan family had been trapped in Islamabad waiting on relocation for eight months. They were connected to the local NHS maternity services on their arrival and a baby daughter was delivered safely in the nearby hospital.

Although there is lots of open space on site for children to play, travelling outside the base is limited to prearranged taxis or car trips organised through the MoD personnel. These are mainly reserved for medical appointments, with a large whiteboard at the entrance mapping the timings of each journey.

One Afghan refugee had told The Independent previously that they were “just staring at the walls” with “nothing to do” and spoke of problems trying to access help.

But a father who we met on the site visit said he was happy that he was finally in the UK with his family, and no longer in the hotels in Islamabad.

Over 3,000 Afghans have been left in limbo in Islamabad since November 2022, after Rishi Sunak pressed to end the use of hotels in the UK and the MoD stopped flights here.

The stalemate was broken at the end of September when the Pakistani government announced that they would expel any undocumented refugees in the country, and the UK’s policy of inaction faced a court challenge.

The Afghan father said: “I arrived at the hotel in Islamabad on 9 November 2022. And we came here on 21 November 2023. It has been one year and 11 days that we have been there. It was a long time.”

He said his children were enjoying being able to freely move around on the base, and explained that he had spent the past year providing free English lessons to Afghans in the Pakistani hotels because the families did not have access to any education.

“I was teaching five classes per day in my hotel without any salary,” he said. “If you do nothing then you think too much in your mind, so I was teaching to ease pressure on myself.

“If I get to my permanent home, I would like to do teaching for a salary and I will proudly do it.”

After Garats Hay, families will be moved on into MoD-owned service homes, depending on the size of the group. Around 700 service homes are available within the MoD estate for families that need 2-3 bedrooms, but those who are travelling alone or in bigger families may have to wait longer for private rented accommodation.

Councils in North Yorkshire, Wiltshire, and Oxfordshire have met the MoD to discuss how the families can be helped into homes within their areas. Those waiting longer for housing are moved into barracks around the county, for an estimated six weeks. At these sites, counsellors help them set up bank accounts and apply for universal credit and housing benefit, although DWP officials have come to Garats Hay to start registering families at the base who will be waiting a bit longer.

One charity is in discussions with the site manager about visiting to provide English lessons for any families who stay at Garats Hay for a longer period. The local community has also responded to news of the Afghans’ arrival by delivering boxes of toys and clothes for the children.

While over 1,000 Afghans eligible for UK resettlement under the MoD’s Arap scheme have been processed through Garats Hay already, there are some 4,000 more who are waiting for relocation in Pakistan and Afghanistan.

Armed forces minister James Heappey told The Independent that they were “working at the best speed we can to get people here”.

A few hundred Afghans who are eligible for relocation to the UK under Home Office and Foreign Office schemes are also stuck in Pakistan. Though some of these have been brought to Britain, the MoD is not responsible for their relocation. The Home Office did not comment on how the rest would be brought to the UK.

Inside the remote army base where hero Afghans are housed after being welcomed to the UK
read more

China Hopes Kabul Further Responds to Intl Expectations

Tolo  News

6 Dec 2023

But he also stressed the importance of building an open and inclusive political structure in Afghanistan.

The Chinese Foreign Ministry’s spokesman, Wang Wenbin, said that China hopes Afghanistan will further respond to the expectations of the international community.

In response to a question about the appointment of Bilal Karimi as the Islamic Emirate’s ambassador in Beijing and whether China will formally recognize the Islamic Emirate, China’s foreign ministry spokesperson Wang Wenbin said: “As a long-standing friendly neighbor of Afghanistan, China believes that Afghanistan should not be excluded from the international community.”

But he also stressed the importance of building an open and inclusive political structure in Afghanistan.

Sayed Jawad Sijadi, a political analyst, said that the international community is pressing their demands on the interim Afghan government.

“The formation of an inclusive government, considering the realities in Afghanistan, recognition of the rights of and freedom of the people of Afghanistan are the demands of the international community of the Taliban. It doesn’t look like the international community will let it fall short on these demands,” he said.
The Chinese FM spokesman hopes Afghanistan will “adopt moderate and prudent domestic and foreign policies, firmly combat all forms of terrorist forces, develop friendly relations with other countries, especially with its neighbors, and integrate itself into the world community.”
“We believe that diplomatic recognition of the Afghan government will come naturally as the concerns of various parties are effectively addressed,” he said.

The Islamic Emirate said that its government is inclusive but stressed it wants to improve relations with the international community.

“The matters that are being mentioned should be mentioned through legal paths, so practical steps are taken for them. We want good relations with all countries and we will provide the grounds for it gradually,” said Zabiullah Mujahid, Islamic Emirate’s spokesman.

Last week, the former deputy spokesman for the Islamic Emirate, Bilal Karimi, presented his credentials to the Director-General of the Protocol Department of the Foreign Ministry of China, Hong Lei.

China Hopes Kabul Further Responds to Intl Expectations
read more

Islamic Emirate Never Sought to Harm Other Countries: Deputy PM

Hanafi also highlighted the increased security in the country as well as efforts to counter narcotics.

The Deputy Prime Minister for Administrative Affairs, Abdul Salam Hanafi, said that the Islamic Emirate never sought to damage other countries, and urged the neighboring countries to be politically neutral towards Afghanistan.

Speaking at a gathering in the Academy of Science of Afghanistan, the Deputy PM said the Islamic Emirate wants to have good relations with all countries and that the foreigners should also not interfere in internal affairs of the country.

“We never seek the construction of our [country] through the destruction of our neighbors. We want both Afghanistan and neighbors to be built up. We have the same hope from our neighbors,” he said.

Hanafi said that the Islamic Emirate does not want to be a member of any of the “coalitions,” referring to Afghanistan’s history and neutrality in World Wars I and II.

“All Afghans are respected in our country. For the Afghans who are abroad due to some concerns, the Islamic Emirate’s message is to return to their country because there is no threat to them,” he said.

The acting Minister of Hajj and Religious Affairs, Noor Mohammad Saqib, told the gathering that research should be continued in various sectors in a bid to pave the way for development in the country.

Abdul Baqi Haqqani, head of the National Examination Authority, said that Afghanistan needs experienced and academic people.

“There is a need for our youth to go out of the country and learn good experiences there and use it in Afghanistan,” he said.

Hanafi also highlighted the increased security in the country as well as efforts to counter narcotics.

Islamic Emirate Never Sought to Harm Other Countries: Deputy PM
read more

West to Kick Off Visits to Region to Discuss Afghanistan

However, some political analysts believe that the visit of the US special envoy for Afghanistan is important considering the current circumstances.

Thomas West, US Special Representative, said that he has started travels to Pakistan, UAE, Qatar, and Saudi Arabia from December 5-15.

“Look forward to meeting with key partners to discuss shared security interests, refugee protection and resettlement, humanitarian needs, human rights, and economic issues,” West said.

Political analyst Torek Farhadi said the West may ask for financial support for the UN operations in Afghanistan.

“Thomas West may seek financial support in the Gulf countries for the UN agencies,” he said.

Meanwhile, the Islamic Emirate’s spokesman, Zabiullah Mujahid, said that Afghanistan wants to improve its relations with the international community.

“Afghanistan itself wants to extend its relations with the countries. And the agenda of the visit of the Americans and its purpose belongs to them,” he said.

However, some political analysts believe that the visit of the US special envoy for Afghanistan is important considering the current circumstances.

“If the US special envoy for Afghanistan is visiting Pakistan, I hope he should come to Afghanistan also. The concerns and propaganda should be shared with the government of Afghanistan,” said Hameedullah Hotak, political analyst.

“Thomas West’s visit is for the interest of the US. It is the Afghan refugees who are suffering from the problems in Iran and Pakistan. I hope the Afghan nation has a plan for consensus and unity in consultation with the current government,” said Zalmai Afghanyar, political analyst.

This comes as Asif Durrani, Pakistan’s Special Representative on Afghanistan, wrote on X that in a meeting with Julieta Valls Noyes, US Assistant Secretary for the Bureau of Population, Refugees, and Migration, they discussed issues concerning Afghan refugees and their resettlement.

West to Kick Off Visits to Region to Discuss Afghanistan
read more

Taliban’s abusive education policies harm boys as well as girls in Afghanistan, rights group says

BY RAHIM FAIEZ
Associated Press

ISLAMABAD (AP) — The Taliban’s “abusive” educational policies are harming boys as well as girls in Afghanistan, according to a Human Rights Watch report published Wednesday.

The Taliban have been globally condemned for banning girls and women from secondary school and university, but the rights group says there has been less attention to the deep harm inflicted on boys’ education.

The departure of qualified teachers including women, regressive curriculum changes and the increase in corporal punishment have led to greater fear of going to school and falling attendance.

“The Taliban are causing irreversible damage to the Afghan education system for boys as well as girls,” said Sahar Fetrat, who wrote the report. “By harming the whole school system in the country, they risk creating a lost generation deprived of a quality education.”

Taliban government spokesmen were not available for comment on the report. The Taliban are prioritizing Islamic knowledge over basic literacy and numeracy with their shift toward madrassas, or religious schools.

The Taliban have barred women from most areas of public life and work and stopped girls from going to school beyond the sixth grade as part of harsh measures they imposed after taking power in 2021.

According to the U.N. children’s agency, more than 1 million girls are affected by the ban, though it estimates 5 million were out of school before the Taliban takeover due to a lack of facilities and other reasons.

The ban remains the Taliban’s biggest obstacle to gaining recognition as the legitimate rulers of Afghanistan. But they have defied the backlash and gone further, excluding women and girls from higher educationpublic spaces like parks and most jobs.

The new report suggests that concerned governments and U.N. agencies should urge the Taliban to end their discriminatory ban on girls’ and women’s education and to stop violating boys’ rights to safe and quality education. That includes by rehiring all women teachers, reforming the curriculum in line with international human rights standards and ending corporal punishment.

“The Taliban’s impact on the education system is harming children today and will haunt Afghanistan’s future,” Fetrat said. “An immediate and effective international response is desperately needed to address Afghanistan’s education crisis.”

 

Taliban’s abusive education policies harm boys as well as girls in Afghanistan, rights group says
read more

Afghans Banned From 16 Provinces In Iran As Forced Exodus Continues

By RFE/RL’s Radio Azadi

Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty

During the past few months, the rate of Afghans deported from Iran has steadily increased despite efforts by Afghanistan's Taliban-run government to persuade Tehran to give the Afghans more time. (file photo)

During the past few months, the rate of Afghans deported from Iran has steadily increased despite efforts by Afghanistan’s Taliban-run government to persuade Tehran to give the Afghans more time. (file photo)

Iran has banned millions of Afghan refugees and migrants in the country from living in, traveling to, or seeking employment in just over half of the country’s 31 provinces.

On December 3, Hamzeh Soleimani, the director-general of citizenship and foreign nationals affairs of the western Kermanshah Province, confirmed the ban was in place in 16 provinces nationwide.

“Numerous construction projects, greenhouses and livestock farms underwent inspection under the plan. [This led] to the arrest and expulsion of Afghan workers from the province,” he said.

Iranian media have identified 15 of the 16 provinces, including Kermanshah, East Azarbaijan, West Azerbaijan, Ardabil, Zanjan, Kurdistan, Hamedan, Gilan, Mazandaran, Sistan-Baluchistan, Ilam, Lorestan, Chaharmahal and Bakhtiari, Kahgiluyeh and Boyer Ahmad, and Hormozgan.

In October, Iranian Interior Minister Ahmad Vahidi reiterated that Tehran would deport all “illegal” migrants, most of whom are Afghan nationals who fled war, persecution, and poverty.

Tehran estimates that more than 5 million Afghans currently live in the country. Iranian officials now want to deport at least half of them because they do not have the documents to remain in the country.

During the past few months, the rate of Afghans deported from Iran has steadily increased despite efforts by Afghanistan’s Taliban-run government to persuade Tehran to give the Afghans more time before embarking on a mass expulsion campaign like Pakistan.

Islamabad is currently deporting thousands of impoverished Afghans daily as part of its campaign to expel more than 1.7 million “undocumented foreigners.”

In Iran, Afghans say their life is becoming more complicated with each passing day.

“The situation of Afghan refugees across Iran is very worrying,” Sharif Mateen, an Afghan refugee, told RFE/RL’s Azadi Radio.

“Police are arresting everyone irrespective of whether they have documents or not. They are then taken to repatriation camps,” he added.

Thousands Of Desperate Afghans Make Risky Journeys Into Iran To Find Work

Iran has hosted millions of Afghans for more than four decades, but Tehran has often complained of the lack of international aid for hosting them.

More than 70 percent of the 3.6 million Afghans who left their country after the Taliban seized back power in August 2021 fled to Iran.

Data show most are educated, middle-class Afghans who served in the fallen pro-Western Afghan republic’s security forces or civil bureaucracy.

Afghans Banned From 16 Provinces In Iran As Forced Exodus Continues
read more

Australia Warns Citizens About Travel to Afghanistan

The Islamic Emirate said Afghanistan is secure and that there is no threat for any foreigner in the country.

Australia’s Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade has extended a warning to its citizens against travel to Afghanistan due to security reasons.

The Ministry said there were ongoing threats of terrorism across Afghanistan including in Kabul and asked its citizens to not travel to Afghanistan.

“There’s an ongoing and very high threat of terrorist attacks throughout Afghanistan, including in Kabul. Terrorists continue to target foreigners, NGOs and humanitarian operations. Foreign nationals, including Australians, also face a serious threat of kidnapping or detention. There are no Australian officials in Afghanistan, and our ability to provide consular and passport assistance to Australians in Afghanistan is severely limited,” reads the notice.

The Islamic Emirate said Afghanistan is secure and that there is no threat for any foreigner in the country.

“No one is in danger in Afghanistan. Travel warnings by countries are incorrect, we see that people are constantly traveling to Afghanistan and no one has been threatened, particularly foreigners who are coming legally,” said Zabiullah Mujahid, spokesperson for the Islamic Emirate.

Meanwhile, military analysts suggested that the caretaker Afghan government should strive to ensure security all over Afghanistan to address the concerns of foreigners.

“The countries have to share their proof of threats and danger with the Islamic Emirate so that the fundamental problems could be dealt with,” said Muhammad Matin Muhammad Khail, a military analyst.

“This is the responsibility of the Islamic Emirate to protect foreigners, diplomats and embassies in the country,” said Sadiq Shinwarai, a military analyst.

Beside Australia, Germany, Russia and UK are other countries which have warned their citizens against travel to Afghanistan.

Earlier, the Russian special envoy for Afghanistan, Zamir Kabulov, had warned Russian citizens not to travel to Afghanistan due to dire security situation in the country.

Australia Warns Citizens About Travel to Afghanistan
read more

Climate Change Unfolding in Afghanistan

TOLOnews reached out to some farmers who shared their deep concerns about the affects of climate changes on their harvests.

The UN Resident Coordinator and Humanitarian Coordinator in Afghanistan, Daniel Peter Endres, expressed concerns over the affects of climate changes in Afghanistan, saying that the climate crisis “today is unfolding” while it has been responsible for just “0.08 percent of global green gas emissions.”  

According to him, the country ranks as the world’s sixth vulnerable and least ready country to address the impacts of climate change.

“Over the past 70 years, Afghanistan has experienced rising temperatures, declining rainfalls and unprecedented level of deforestation,” Endres said in a video released by OCHA Afghanistan.

Meanwhile, the spokesman of the State Ministry for Disaster Management, Mullah Jan Saiq, said that if the current impacts of the climate changes are not addressed in Afghanistan, it will cause huge damages to the country.

“Due to the shortage of rainfalls and drought in recent years, the people have sustained very damages. The people in the coming winter will face more harm,” he said.

TOLOnews reached out to some farmers who shared their deep concerns about the affects of climate changes on their harvests.

“There is a severe drought in the country. Farming is very challenging and the harvests are not good in their seasons,” said Sadiq Khan, a farmer.

This comes as the 2023 United Nations Climate Change Conference known as COP 28 hosted by the UAE invited no representative from Afghanistan.

Climate Change Unfolding in Afghanistan
read more

Situation of Afghan Women Discussed in Meeting of Opposition

Some of the participants of the meeting told TOLOnews that the participants discussed the situation of the women in Afghanistan.

 The participants of a meeting of opposition figures of the Islamic Emirate called for a roadmap and a framework for Afghanistan’s future.

The meeting was held in Vienna. Some of the participants of the meeting told TOLOnews that the participants discussed the situation of the women in Afghanistan.

“On day three, the agenda will discuss the presence of women in the political sector in Afghanistan because they are deprived of all their rights and discuss how women can reach their rights back,” said Fazal Ahmad Manavi, a participant of the Vienna meeting.

“The close up of the discussion of the past two days is part of the agenda,” said Sayed Baqir Mohseni, a participant of the meeting.

Earlier, Suhail Shaheen, head of the Islamic Emirate’s political office based in Qatar, criticized the meetings and considered it not in the interest of the people of Afghanistan.

The meeting was attended by the opposition of the Islamic Emirate, civil rights activists and envoys of some countries.

Situation of Afghan Women Discussed in Meeting of Opposition
read more